Contract analysis
Clause-by-clause risk read on any document of the firm. Pick a contract, or open any document from a matter.
Contract analysis / trial-demonstratives-damages.pptx
trial-demonstratives-damages.pptx
High · 0
Medium · 0
Standard · 1
1. Deliberate Copying: Lumicore engineers reviewed OWS published patent applications durin
1. Deliberate Copying: Lumicore engineers reviewed OWS published patent applications during design phase (Michaud deposition; Chen testimony)
2. Good-Faith Investigation: Lumicore claims 'competent legal opinions' but refuses to pro
2. Good-Faith Investigation: Lumicore claims 'competent legal opinions' but refuses to produce them; no design-around before LumiEdge launch
3. Litigation Conduct: Lumicore has resisted discovery, asserting privilege over critical
3. Litigation Conduct: Lumicore has resisted discovery, asserting privilege over critical opinion letters
4. Size and Financial Condition: Lumicore is a $3.4B market-cap public company with resour
4. Size and Financial Condition: Lumicore is a $3.4B market-cap public company with resources to license or design around
5. Closeness of the Case: Strong infringement evidence across all four patents and three p
5. Closeness of the Case: Strong infringement evidence across all four patents and three product lines
6. Duration of Misconduct: Over two years of continued infringement after notice (Jan 2023
6. Duration of Misconduct: Over two years of continued infringement after notice (Jan 2023 – present)
7. Remedial Action: None — Lumicore continues to sell all accused products without modific
7. Remedial Action: None — Lumicore continues to sell all accused products without modification
8. Motivation: Accused products represent ~$264.9M / ~84.7% of Lumicore's FY 2023 revenue
8. Motivation: Accused products represent ~$264.9M / ~84.7% of Lumicore's FY 2023 revenue — powerful financial incentive
9. Attempted Concealment: Refusal to produce opinion letters and privilege assertions over
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
9. Attempted Concealment: Refusal to produce opinion letters and privilege assertions over relevant communications [slide 18] Impact of a Permanent Injunction OWS seeks permanent injunction barring Lumicore from making, using, selling, or importing accused products Approximately 42% of Lumicore's product revenue would be affected Lumicore estimates redesign would take 18–24 months Damages award compensates for past i