Contract analysis
Clause-by-clause risk read on any document of the firm. Pick a contract, or open any document from a matter.
Contract analysis / preliminary-tax-structure-memo.docx
preliminary-tax-structure-memo.docx
High · 4
Medium · 1
Standard · 5
I. Executive Summary
I. Executive Summary Calderwood & Harkness LLP represents Aurelius Global Media Group PLC ("Aurelius" or "AGMG"), a UK public limited company (Companies House No. 08431276), in connection with the proposed carve-out and divestiture of its legacy publishing division. The publishing division operates through Meridian Press Holdings LLC ("MPH"), a Delaware limited liability company (file no. 4521889), which is wholly ow
II. Current Corporate and Tax Structure
High
⚑ Uncapped liability exposure
II. Current Corporate and Tax Structure A. Aurelius Group Structure — Relevant Entities The following entities are relevant to the analysis of the proposed transaction: Aurelius Global Media Group PLC ("Aurelius" or "AGMG"). Aurelius is the UK-headquartered, publicly listed ultimate parent entity of the Aurelius group of companies. It maintains a Premium Listing on the London Stock Exchange and sponsors a Level II Am
III. US Federal Income Tax Treatment of the Proposed Transaction
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
III. US Federal Income Tax Treatment of the Proposed Transaction A. Sale of Membership Interests in a Disregarded Entity As discussed in Section II.B above, MPH is a disregarded entity for US federal income tax purposes. The fundamental consequence of this classification is that a sale of 100% of the membership interests in MPH to Buyer is treated, for US federal income tax purposes, as a sale by AMH of all of the un
Section 338(h)(10) of the Internal Revenue Code provides a mechanism by which the buyer an
High
⚑ Non-compete / exclusivity restraint
Section 338(h)(10) of the Internal Revenue Code provides a mechanism by which the buyer and seller of a "qualified stock purchase" of a target may jointly elect to treat the stock acquisition as a deemed asset acquisition for federal income tax purposes. When this election is made, the target is treated as having sold all of its assets in a single transaction at fair market value and then liquidated, rather than bein
IV. Estimated US Tax Liability to Seller
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
IV. Estimated US Tax Liability to Seller A. Estimated Taxable Gain The estimated taxable gain to Seller arising from the proposed transaction is calculated as follows: The estimated aggregate adjusted tax basis of $252,000,000 is based on a preliminary analysis of historical cost, accumulated depreciation, and amortization schedules for MPH's assets, as well as AMH's adjusted tax basis in the stock of MDS and Bellwea
V. UK Tax Considerations
Medium
⚑ Liability cap to check against exposure
V. UK Tax Considerations A. Substantial Shareholding Exemption (SSE) Analysis Aurelius Global Media Group PLC is a UK tax resident company. While the disposal of the publishing division occurs at the AMH level — a US subsidiary of Aurelius — it is necessary to analyze the upstream UK tax consequences of the transaction, including the potential application of the UK controlled foreign company ("CFC") rules and the ava
VI. State and Local Tax Implications
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
VI. State and Local Tax Implications A. Nexus States and Apportionment AMH and MPH have nexus for state and local income tax purposes in multiple jurisdictions by virtue of MPH's physical presence, employees, property, and revenue-generating activities. The following is a summary of the principal nexus states and the key considerations applicable to each: New Jersey. MPH operates a distribution center at 45 Fieldcres
VII. Canadian Tax Considerations
High
⚑ Uncapped liability exposure
VII. Canadian Tax Considerations A. Meridian Press Canada ULC Meridian Press Canada ULC ("Meridian Canada") is a British Columbia unlimited liability company that conducts the Canadian operations of the publishing division. As noted in Section II.B, a ULC organized under British Columbia law is a flow-through entity for Canadian federal and provincial income tax purposes, meaning that its income and gains are general
VIII. Transfer Taxes
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
VIII. Transfer Taxes A. Overview The sale of membership interests in a Delaware limited liability company is generally not subject to state transfer taxes in most jurisdictions. Transfer taxes — including real property transfer taxes, deed recording taxes, and stamp duties — are typically imposed on the transfer of real property or, in some states, on the transfer of a controlling interest in an entity that owns real
IX. Tax Structuring Recommendations
IX. Tax Structuring Recommendations A. Summary of Recommendations Based on the foregoing analysis, we make the following preliminary recommendations for the tax structuring of the proposed transaction:
1. Proceed with membership interest sale structure. The sale of 100% of the MPH membershi
1. Proceed with membership interest sale structure. The sale of 100% of the MPH membership interests is the preferred transaction structure from a tax perspective. This structure provides a deemed asset sale at the MPH level by virtue of MPH's disregarded entity classification, resulting in a step-up in the tax basis of MPH's assets for Buyer, while preserving a clean legal transfer at the entity level. The membershi
2. Agree to Section 338(h)(10) election for MDS and Bellweather. We recommend that Seller
Standard
⚑ Commercial term
2. Agree to Section 338(h)(10) election for MDS and Bellweather. We recommend that Seller agree to Buyer's expected request for a Section 338(h)(10) election with respect to MDS and Bellweather, subject to the following conditions: (a) the purchase price allocation among asset classes shall be mutually agreed between Buyer and Seller and documented in a separate Section 338(h)(10) Election Agreement; (b) Buyer shall
3. UK SSE / CFC analysis. We recommend coordinating with Aurelius's UK tax advisors to co
3. UK SSE / CFC analysis. We recommend coordinating with Aurelius's UK tax advisors to confirm that no UK corporation tax liability arises from the transaction. Based on our preliminary analysis, no direct UK corporate tax is expected: the disposal is made by AMH (a non-UK entity), the assets are located outside the UK, and the SSE would be available if the transaction were restructured as a share disposal. The CFC a
4. State tax planning. We recommend performing a detailed state-by-state modeling exercis
4. State tax planning. We recommend performing a detailed state-by-state modeling exercise to quantify the state income tax exposure and identify opportunities to minimize the state tax burden through apportionment optimization. This analysis should confirm conformity with the Section 338(h)(10) election in each nexus state and evaluate the potential for combined/unitary filing to reduce the overall state effective t
5. Canadian subsidiary. We recommend engaging Canadian tax counsel promptly to conduct a
5. Canadian subsidiary. We recommend engaging Canadian tax counsel promptly to conduct a detailed analysis of the Canadian federal and provincial tax consequences of the transaction as it relates to Meridian Press Canada ULC. The Canadian analysis should address deemed disposition issues, withholding obligations, and Canada-US Tax Treaty implications, as well as Competition Act clearance requirements for the Canadian
6. Transfer taxes. We recommend conducting a jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction analysis of rea
6. Transfer taxes. We recommend conducting a jurisdiction-by-jurisdiction analysis of real property transfer tax and controlling interest transfer tax exposure in New Jersey, Ohio, Texas, and Nevada. The transfer tax analysis should identify any available exemptions or exclusions and quantify the estimated transfer tax liability in each jurisdiction. The anticipated 50/50 sharing arrangement between Buyer and Seller
7. FIRPTA certificate. We will prepare a non-foreign affidavit (FIRPTA certificate) for A
7. FIRPTA certificate. We will prepare a non-foreign affidavit (FIRPTA certificate) for AMH to deliver to Buyer at closing, certifying that AMH is not a "foreign person" within the meaning of Section 1445 of the Internal Revenue Code. This is a customary closing deliverable that will eliminate any FIRPTA withholding obligation on the part of Buyer.
8. Tax indemnification provisions. In the MIPA, we recommend including comprehensive tax
High
⚑ Indemnity / guarantee obligation
8. Tax indemnification provisions. In the MIPA, we recommend including comprehensive tax representations, warranties, and indemnification provisions. These provisions should address, at a minimum: (a) the accuracy and completeness of MPH's tax returns; (b) the absence of undisclosed tax liabilities; (c) compliance with applicable tax laws; (d) the treatment of intercompany transactions; (e) the absence of tax-sharing
1. Tax basis schedules. Obtain detailed adjusted tax basis schedules from Pemberton Grave
1. Tax basis schedules. Obtain detailed adjusted tax basis schedules from Pemberton Graves LLP (Robert Ainsley, engagement p