FR EA
1017-00003 · Aurelius Global Media Group · Factual Investigation
infringement-timeline-evidence-matrix.xlsx DOCUMENT Litigation
20 / 37 ← → ✕
Contract analysis Extract to table

[sheet: Timeline & Evidence Matrix]

Entry No.DateEvent DescriptionCategorySource / WitnessDocument ReferenceEvidentiary SignificanceClaim(s) SupportedNotes
12017 (approx.)Franklin Ogilvie begins employment at Aurelius Media Americas, Inc. as a mid-level licensing managerBackgroundAurelius Media Americas HR records; Fiona Hartwell (GC, Aurelius)Ogilvie Personnel File; AMA Employment RecordsEstablishes Ogilvie's access to Aurelius content management systems and knowledge of Aurelius's content library, licensing practices, and proprietary information; foundational for breach of separation agreement and contributory/inducement claimsContributory Infringement; Inducement; Breach of Separation Agreement; FraudOgilvie served as licensing manager with access to content management systems; approximately 4 years of employment
2June 30, 2021Franklin Ogilvie's employment at Aurelius Media Americas, Inc. ends following internal investigation into unauthorized access to Aurelius's content management systems; separation agreement executedBackgroundFiona Hartwell (GC, Aurelius); Aurelius Media Americas HR / Legal DepartmentOgilvie Separation Agreement (dated June 30, 2021); Internal Investigation ReportSeparation agreement includes non-compete, non-solicitation, and explicit prohibition on use of any Aurelius intellectual property; establishes that Ogilvie had no post-employment authority over Aurelius content and was specifically barred from using Aurelius IPBreach of Separation Agreement; Contributory Infringement; Inducement; Fraud; Willfulness (StreamNow due diligence failure)Ogilvie's departure was involuntary following misconduct investigation; separation terms are highly restrictive
3Late 2021Meridian Digital Distributors, LLC incorporated in California by Franklin Ogilvie as sole member/managerBackgroundCalifornia Secretary of State business recordsCA SOS Filing — File No. 202115729430; MDD Articles of OrganizationMDD formed shortly after Ogilvie's separation from Aurelius; temporal proximity supports inference that Ogilvie formed MDD to exploit knowledge and materials gained during Aurelius employment; MDD never authorized by Aurelius as distributorContributory Infringement; Inducement; Breach of Separation Agreement; FraudRegistered address: 8912 Burton Way, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90211
4June 2022Pinnacle Ventures Fund III, LP closes $145 million Series C investment in StreamNow Holdings, Inc., acquiring approximately 62% of fully diluted equityBackgroundPublic filings / press reports; Howard Cheng (Managing Partner, Pinnacle Ventures)StreamNow Series C closing documents (if obtained in discovery)Establishes StreamNow's financial sophistication and resources; relevant to willfulness analysis (StreamNow had resources to conduct due diligence on content sources); Pinnacle Ventures Management III, LLC serves as GPWillfulnessPinnacle Ventures headquartered at 101 California Street, Suite 3500, San Francisco, CA 94111
5March 15, 2024Meridian Digital Distributors, LLC and StreamNow Holdings, Inc. allegedly execute 'Content Distribution Agreement' covering 350+ titles, including 217 Aurelius-owned titlesInfringement ConductSandra Yee (VP, Content Acquisition, StreamNow) — referenced in November 3, 2025 email; MDD / Franklin OgilvieMDD–StreamNow Content Distribution Agreement (dated March 15, 2024); Yee Email (November 3, 2025)Core document establishing the unauthorized chain of distribution; MDD had no authority to license any Aurelius content; Aurelius never granted MDD any license, sublicense, or distribution rights; StreamNow's failure to verify MDD's authority supports willfulnessDirect Infringement; Contributory Infringement; Inducement; Willfulness; FraudAgreement purportedly covered 350+ titles; 217 are Aurelius-owned works (142 films + 75 TV series comprising 1,038 episodes)
6April 1, 2024 (approx.)StreamNow begins ingesting Aurelius-owned titles into its platform library; first unauthorized reproduction, distribution, and public performance of Aurelius content commencesInfringement ConductDr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics, LLC) — metadata extraction and content fingerprinting; platform ingestion logsCipherTrace Forensic Analysis Report; StreamNow platform metadata recordsMarks the start of the 22-month infringement period (April 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026); establishes date of first infringing act; relevant to statute of limitations analysis under 17 U.S.C. § 507(b)Direct Infringement (17 U.S.C. §§ 106, 501 — reproduction, distribution, public performance)217 titles made available for streaming to subscribers in the U.S., Canada, Australia, and 11 additional territories (14 countries total)
7April 2024 – January 2026 (ongoing)StreamNow makes Aurelius content continuously available to subscribers across subscription and AVOD tiers in 14 countries; exercises editorial control over catalog selection, pricing tiers, and geographic availabilityInfringement ConductDr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics); StreamNow platform dataCipherTrace Forensic Analysis Report; StreamNow subscriber and viewership dataDemonstrates ongoing, continuous infringement over 22-month period; StreamNow's active curation and monetization role negates DMCA § 512 safe harbor defense; key franchises affected include Meridian (6 films, $1.43B global box office), Iron Compass (4 seasons, 48 episodes, 9.2M avg. UK viewers/episode), and Thornfield (12 titles, 7 BAFTA awards)Direct Infringement; DMCA Safe Harbor Non-Applicability; Willfulness; UCL § 17200StreamNow is not a passive hosting service — actively curates, licenses (purports to), and monetizes content
8April 2024 – January 2026 (ongoing)StreamNow sublicenses bundles containing Aurelius content to four third-party FAST channel operators: Brindoval Channel Networks, Inc. (Dallas, TX), BrightLoop Media, LLC (Miami, FL), Velvet Stream Partners, LP (Toronto, ON, Canada), and Pacific Lantern Digital Pty Ltd (Sydney, NSW, Australia)Infringement ConductDr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics); StreamNow sublicense records (anticipated in discovery)CipherTrace Forensic Analysis Report; StreamNow FAST sublicense agreements; FAST Channel Sublicensee Identification MemorandumExpands the scope of unauthorized distribution beyond StreamNow's own platform; sublicensing fees of $6.5 million attributable to Aurelius content; each sublicensee is a potential secondary infringerDirect Infringement; Contributory Infringement; WillfulnessSublicensing revenue is one of three attributable revenue streams ($6.5M of $38.6M total)
9May 2024 – October 202528 Aurelius titles receive U.S. Copyright Office registrations post-dating commencement of infringement (late registrations)Background / RegistrationMarissa Chung (Lexington IP Services, Inc.); U.S. Copyright Office recordsCopyright Registration Summary Report (Lexington IP Services search completed January 22, 2026)These 28 titles are eligible for actual damages and infringer's profits only (not statutory damages or attorneys' fees); distinguished from the 189 timely-registered titles that are eligible for full statutory damages up to $150,000/work and attorneys' fees under 17 U.S.C. §§ 504(c)(2), 505Direct Infringement (remedies analysis)189 titles timely registered (within 3 months of first publication or before infringement); 28 registered late
10October 15, 2025Lena Kowalski, Head of Digital Rights Enforcement at Aurelius, discovers Aurelius-owned titles streaming on the StreamNow platformDiscovery & InvestigationLena Kowalski (Aurelius)Draft Declaration of Lena Kowalski; Kowalski internal reports / screenshotsDate of discovery of infringement; critical for statute of limitations accrual analysis under discovery rule; triggers Aurelius's obligation to investigate and duty to mitigate; establishes Aurelius had no prior knowledge of the unauthorized useDirect Infringement; Statute of Limitations; WillfulnessKowalski identified titles including Meridian franchise, Iron Compass series, and Thornfield catalog on the platform
11October 22, 2025Lena Kowalski escalates discovery to Fiona Hartwell, General Counsel of Aurelius; internal investigation beginsDiscovery & InvestigationLena Kowalski; Fiona Hartwell (GC, Aurelius)Internal escalation email / memo (Kowalski to Hartwell); Internal investigation fileDemonstrates prompt escalation and diligent client response; internal investigation confirms Aurelius never authorized MDD or StreamNow; supports argument against laches defenseDirect Infringement; WillfulnessInvestigation included review of Aurelius licensing records, MDD status, and Ogilvie separation agreement
12November 3, 2025Sandra Yee (VP, Content Acquisition, StreamNow) responds to informal inquiry from Raj Anantharam (SVP, Content Licensing & Distribution, Aurelius) via email, claiming that StreamNow obtained Aurelius content through a sublicense from Meridian Digital Distributors, LLCCorrespondenceSandra Yee (StreamNow); Raj Anantharam (Aurelius)Yee Email dated November 3, 2025Key admission by StreamNow identifying MDD as purported source of rights; establishes StreamNow's awareness of the provenance question; MDD's principal (Franklin Ogilvie) is a former Aurelius employee whose separation agreement barred use of Aurelius IP — StreamNow's failure to investigate this red flag supports willfulness; Aurelius records confirm MDD was never an authorized distributorDirect Infringement; Willfulness; Contributory Infringement (MDD/Ogilvie)Email identifies the MDD–StreamNow Content Distribution Agreement dated March 15, 2024 as the claimed source of authority
13November 18, 2025Aurelius engages Bexley Marsh Solicitors LLP (London) for preliminary assessment of UK and U.S. copyright claimsEngagement & CounselFiona Hartwell (Aurelius GC)Bexley Marsh engagement correspondenceDemonstrates Aurelius's prompt pursuit of legal remedies; Bexley Marsh is Aurelius's UK IP counsel (14 Bedford Row, London WC1R 4ED)Procedural — diligenceUK counsel engagement preceded U.S. counsel referral
14December 5, 2025Bexley Marsh Solicitors LLP recommends engagement of U.S. counsel for U.S. copyright claims given that infringement is centered on U.S.-based platform and U.S. Copyright Act governsEngagement & CounselBexley Marsh Solicitors LLPBexley Marsh recommendation letter / memoEstablishes basis for U.S. counsel engagement; confirms that primary claims arise under U.S. Copyright Act (17 U.S.C. §§ 106, 501) with proposed venue in U.S. District Court for the Central District of CaliforniaProcedural — jurisdiction / venueStreamNow headquartered in Los Angeles (C.D. Cal.); MDD registered in California
15January 8, 2026Aurelius contacts Calderwood & Harkness LLP regarding potential U.S. copyright infringement engagementEngagement & CounselFiona Hartwell (Aurelius GC); Marcus Delgado (Partner, Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Initial contact correspondenceFirst contact with U.S. outside counsel; Calderwood & Harkness LLP, 1999 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90067ProceduralC&H LA office selected given proximity to StreamNow, MDD, and C.D. Cal.
16January 15, 2026Initial consultation between Marcus Delgado (Calderwood & Harkness) and Fiona Hartwell (Aurelius GC); scope of pre-suit work discussedEngagement & CounselMarcus Delgado; Fiona HartwellEmail — Delgado to Hartwell re: Initial Consultation Follow-Up (dated January 16, 2026)Establishes scope of pre-suit assessment; Delgado requests key documents including Ogilvie separation agreement, internal investigation files, licensing records, and Sandra Yee November 3, 2025 email; identifies need to retain CipherTrace Analytics and Lexington IP ServicesProceduralFollow-up email confirms proposed engagement team: Delgado (responsible partner), Catherine Bloom (billing partner), Wendy Schultz (lead associate), Omar Siddiqui (working associate)
17January 22, 2026Lexington IP Services, Inc. (Marissa Chung, Director of Copyright Research) completes U.S. Copyright Office registration verification and chain-of-title search for all 217 titlesExpert AnalysisMarissa Chung (Lexington IP Services, Inc.)Copyright Registration Summary Report; Lexington IP Services search resultsConfirms registration status for all 217 titles: 189 timely registrations (eligible for statutory damages up to $150,000/work under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c)(2) and attorneys' fees under § 505); 28 late registrations (actual damages and profits only); total statutory damages maximum for 217 works = $32,550,000 (217 × $150,000)Direct Infringement (registration prerequisite); RemediesLexington IP Services, Inc., 1625 I Street NW, Suite 400, Washington, DC 20006; estimated fee $28,500
18January 31, 2026End of measured infringement period (22 months from April 1, 2024); infringement ongoing as of this dateInfringement ConductDr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics)CipherTrace Forensic Analysis ReportDefines the 22-month measurement window for damages calculations; total attributable revenue during this period: $38.6 million ($22.4M subscription + $9.7M advertising + $6.5M sublicensing); Aurelius's lost licensing revenue estimated at $14.2M; Hargrove preliminary net recoverable damages estimate: $41.3 millionDirect Infringement; DamagesInfringement has not ceased as of this date; continuing infringement supports injunctive relief
19February 10, 2026Calderwood & Harkness completes conflict-of-interest check for representation of Aurelius against StreamNow, MDD, and related parties (including Pinnacle Ventures Fund III, LP, Derek Calloway, Priya Menon, Tobias Rennert, Franklin Ogilvie, Grantham Roth & Pearce LLP, and FAST sublicensees); no conflicts identifiedEngagement & CounselWendy Schultz; Marcus Delgado (Calderwood & Harkness)Conflict Check Memorandum (dated February 10, 2026)Clears engagement; confirms no prior or current representation of any adverse partyProceduralStreamNow's outside counsel identified as Grantham Roth & Pearce LLP (Victoria Langford, partner; Brian Matsuda, associate), 555 South Flower Street, Suite 4200, Los Angeles, CA 90071
20February 12, 2026Calderwood & Harkness LLP engagement formally opened (Matter No. 1017-00003); engagement letter executed with AureliusEngagement & CounselMarcus Delgado; Catherine Bloom; Fiona HartwellEngagement Letter — Calderwood & Harkness to Aurelius (dated February 12, 2026)Formalizes representation; scope: pre-suit copyright infringement assessment and demand against StreamNow; fee terms: hourly ($1,350/hr Delgado, $1,275/hr Bloom, $895/hr Schultz, $725/hr Siddiqui) plus 5% success fee on recovery exceeding $20M (capped at $2M); estimated pre-suit budget $485,000; retainer $150,000ProceduralGoverning law: California
21February 14, 2026$150,000 retainer received from Aurelius; litigation hold notice issued to Aurelius and Aurelius Media Americas, Inc.Engagement & CounselMarcus Delgado; Fiona Hartwell; Lena Kowalski; Raj AnantharamLitigation Hold Notice (dated February 14, 2026); Retainer receipt confirmationPreservation obligation established for all documents, communications, and ESI relating to the 217 titles, StreamNow, MDD, Franklin Ogilvie, and all licensing of Aurelius content; hold cascaded to key custodiansProcedural — preservationCovers email, content management system records, licensing databases, and internal investigation files
22February 15, 2026Wendy Schultz assigns initial research tasks to Omar Siddiqui: jurisdictional/venue analysis (C.D. Cal.), statute of limitations, Ogilvie/MDD background, StreamNow corporate structure and business model, FAST sublicensee identificationEngagement & CounselWendy Schultz; Omar SiddiquiEmail — Schultz to Siddiqui re: Research Assignments (dated February 15, 2026)Documents work plan for pre-suit investigation phaseProcedural
23February 18, 2026Calderwood & Harkness retains CipherTrace Analytics, LLC (Dr. Nathan Frey) as digital forensics and technical expert for content fingerprinting, metadata extraction, viewership/traffic analysis, and revenue attributionExpert AnalysisDr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics, LLC)Expert Retention Letter — CipherTrace Analytics (dated February 18, 2026)Expert retained under attorney-client privilege for anticipated litigation; scope includes forensic confirmation of 217 titles on StreamNow platform, revenue attribution modeling; estimated fee $175,000Direct Infringement; DamagesCipherTrace Analytics, LLC, 2700 Sand Hill Road, Suite 130, Menlo Park, CA 94025
24February 20, 2026Calderwood & Harkness retains Hargrove Economic Consulting Group, LLC (Dr. Elena Vasquez) as damages and economic expert for preliminary damages modelingExpert AnalysisDr. Elena Vasquez (Hargrove Economic Consulting Group, LLC)Expert Retention Letter — Hargrove Economic Consulting (dated February 20, 2026)Scope includes analysis of actual damages (lost licensing revenue of $14.2M), infringer's profits ($38.6M), apportionment to avoid double-counting, comparison with statutory damages alternative ($32,550,000); estimated fee $95,000; preliminary net recoverable damages estimate: $41.3 millionDamagesHargrove Economic Consulting Group, LLC, 350 South Grand Avenue, Suite 2800, Los Angeles, CA 90071
25February 22, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes background research memorandum on Franklin Ogilvie documenting employment history at Aurelius Media Americas (approx. 2017–June 30, 2021), internal investigation, separation agreement terms, and formation of MDDDiscovery & InvestigationOmar Siddiqui (Calderwood & Harkness)Franklin Ogilvie Background Memorandum (dated February 22, 2026)Establishes Ogilvie's knowledge of Aurelius content, post-employment restrictions, and formation of MDD in breach of separation agreement; supports claims for contributory infringement, inducement, breach of separation agreement, and fraud against Ogilvie/MDDContributory Infringement; Inducement; Breach of Separation Agreement; Fraud
26February 24, 2026Calderwood & Harkness completes insurance coverage analysis of Fortbridge Specialty Insurance Company media liability / IP enforcement policy (Policy No. FSI-ML-2024-07821)Engagement & CounselWendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness)Insurance Coverage Analysis Memorandum (dated February 24, 2026)Policy provides $25M per occurrence / $50M aggregate for media perils and IP enforcement; analysis of whether policy covers enforcement litigation costs; recommends timely claim tender; broker: Calder & Whitfield Insurance Brokers Ltd. (71 Fenchurch Street, London EC3M 4BS)Procedural — insuranceFortbridge Specialty Insurance Company, 280 Trumbull Street, Hartford, CT 06103
27February 25, 2026Omar Siddiqui and Wendy Schultz complete chain-of-title memorandum confirming Aurelius's ownership of all 217 works; no gaps identified in chain of titleDiscovery & InvestigationOmar Siddiqui; Wendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness)Chain-of-Title Memorandum (dated February 25, 2026)Confirms that Aurelius Global Media Group PLC and/or Aurelius Media Americas, Inc. hold all relevant U.S. copyrights for the 217 works; cross-references Lexington IP Services registration data; satisfies ownership element of copyright infringement claimDirect Infringement (ownership element)Traces ownership from original production/acquisition through transfers, work-for-hire documentation, and assignment records
28February 26, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes statute of limitations analysis under 17 U.S.C. § 507(b); all claims determined to be timelyEngagement & CounselOmar Siddiqui (Calderwood & Harkness)Statute of Limitations Analysis Memorandum (dated February 26, 2026)Three-year limitations period under § 507(b); infringement commenced April 1, 2024, discovered October 15, 2025; all claims timely under both discovery and injury rules; evaluates potential laches defenses — none viable given prompt pursuit of claimsStatute of LimitationsReferences Supreme Court Petrella and Warner Chappell decisions
29February 27, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes jurisdictional and venue analysis confirming C.D. Cal. as proper forumEngagement & CounselOmar Siddiqui (Calderwood & Harkness)Jurisdictional & Venue Analysis Memorandum (dated February 27, 2026)Federal subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1338 (copyright); personal jurisdiction over StreamNow (HQ in Los Angeles) and MDD (registered in California); venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1400(a); supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367 for § 17200 claimProcedural — jurisdiction / venueStreamNow HQ: 3400 Wilshire Blvd, Suite 1800, Los Angeles, CA 90010; MDD: 8912 Burton Way, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90211
30February 28, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes StreamNow platform and business model memorandum analyzing StreamNow's super-aggregator model, corporate structure, revenue model, and DMCA safe harbor inapplicabilityDiscovery & InvestigationOmar Siddiqui (Calderwood & Harkness)StreamNow Platform & Business Model Memorandum (dated February 28, 2026)StreamNow is a Delaware corporation (File No. 7291843), majority-owned (~62%) by Pinnacle Ventures Fund III, LP; estimated FY2025 revenue $312M; operates in 14 countries; exercises editorial control over catalog — negates DMCA § 512 safe harborDMCA Safe Harbor Non-Applicability; Direct InfringementStreamNow founded 2019; CEO Derek Calloway, COO Priya Menon, GC Tobias Rennert, VP Content Acquisition Sandra Yee
31March 1, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes FAST channel sublicensee identification memorandum; Calderwood & Harkness sends notice of claim to Fortbridge Specialty Insurance CompanyDiscovery & Investigation / Engagement & CounselOmar Siddiqui; Catherine Bloom (Calderwood & Harkness)FAST Channel Sublicensee Identification Memorandum (dated March 1, 2026); Notice of Claim Letter — Fortbridge (dated March 1, 2026)Identifies 4 downstream FAST sublicensees receiving unauthorized Aurelius content; insurance claim tendered under Policy No. FSI-ML-2024-07821 for enforcement litigation costs; estimated damages of $41.3M communicated to carrierContributory Infringement (sublicensees); Procedural — insuranceSublicensees: Brindoval Channel Networks (Dallas, TX), BrightLoop Media (Miami, FL), Velvet Stream Partners (Toronto, ON), Pacific Lantern Digital (Sydney, NSW)
32March 2, 2026Wendy Schultz completes analysis of the purported MDD–StreamNow Content Distribution Agreement (dated March 15, 2024); concludes MDD had no authority to grant any license over Aurelius contentDiscovery & InvestigationWendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness)MDD–StreamNow Content Distribution Agreement Analysis Memorandum (dated March 2, 2026)MDD never authorized by Aurelius as distributor; StreamNow's reliance on MDD's representations does not constitute valid defense; 'innocent infringer' argument fails given due diligence red flags (Ogilvie's former Aurelius employment, MDD's lack of verifiable rights)Direct Infringement; Willfulness; Contributory InfringementAgreement purportedly covered 350+ titles; 217 are Aurelius works
33March 3, 2026Wendy Schultz completes detailed copyright infringement claim analysis under 17 U.S.C. §§ 106, 501Engagement & CounselWendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness)Copyright Infringement Claim Analysis (dated March 3, 2026)Confirms all elements satisfied: ownership (chain of title confirmed), copying/access (verbatim reproduction — substantial similarity not at issue), violation of exclusive rights (reproduction, distribution, public performance); distinguishes 189 timely vs. 28 late-registered works for remediesDirect Infringement (17 U.S.C. §§ 106, 501)
34March 4, 2026Wendy Schultz completes DMCA safe harbor non-applicability analysis; Omar Siddiqui and Wendy Schultz complete willfulness analysisEngagement & CounselWendy Schultz; Omar Siddiqui (Calderwood & Harkness)DMCA Safe Harbor Non-Applicability Memorandum (dated March 4, 2026); Willfulness Analysis Memorandum (dated March 4, 2026)StreamNow does not qualify for DMCA § 512 safe harbor — not a passive hosting service; actively curates, licenses, and monetizes content; willfulness supported by: failure to conduct due diligence on MDD, Ogilvie's known former Aurelius employment, scale/duration (217 titles, 22 months), StreamNow's sophistication, continued exploitation after Aurelius raised concerns; enhanced statutory damages cap $150,000/workDMCA Safe Harbor Non-Applicability; WillfulnessDiscusses relevant Ninth Circuit precedent
35March 5, 2026Omar Siddiqui completes Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 supplemental claim analysis; CipherTrace forensic analysis summary completedExpert Analysis / Engagement & CounselOmar Siddiqui; Dr. Nathan Frey (CipherTrace Analytics)Cal. Bus. & Prof. Code § 17200 Supplemental Claim Memorandum (dated March 5, 2026); CipherTrace Forensic Analysis Summary (dated March 5, 2026)§ 17200 claim viable — StreamNow's unauthorized distribution is unlawful and unfair; restitution and injunctive relief available; federal preemption issues addressed; CipherTrace confirms 217 Aurelius titles present on StreamNow platform with revenue attribution: $22.4M subscription + $9.7M advertising + $6.5M sublicensing = $38.6M totalUCL § 17200; Direct Infringement; DamagesCipherTrace analysis prepared under attorney direction by Omar Siddiqui and Wendy Schultz
36March 6, 2026Wendy Schultz completes damages analysis memorandum synthesizing Hargrove preliminary model and statutory damages alternativeEngagement & CounselWendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness); Dr. Elena Vasquez (Hargrove Economic Consulting)Damages Analysis Memorandum (dated March 6, 2026)Actual damages theory: Aurelius lost licensing revenue $14.2M + StreamNow attributable profits $38.6M, apportioned to avoid double-counting = $41.3M net recoverable (Hargrove preliminary estimate); statutory alternative: $32,550,000 (217 × $150,000); recommends pursuing actual damages + profits as primary theory; attorneys' fees recoverable under 17 U.S.C. § 505 for 189 timely-registered worksDamagesActual damages + profits theory yields higher recovery than statutory maximum
37March 7, 2026Marcus Delgado and Wendy Schultz complete comprehensive pre-suit assessment memorandum and transmit to Fiona HartwellEngagement & CounselMarcus Delgado; Wendy Schultz; Fiona HartwellPre-Suit Assessment Memorandum (dated March 7, 2026)Comprehensive analysis covering all claims (federal copyright, DMCA, willfulness, § 17200, tortious interference, claims against Ogilvie/MDD), jurisdiction/venue (C.D. Cal.), statute of limitations, damages ($41.3M vs. $32.55M statutory), strengths/weaknesses, anticipated defenses, recommended strategy (demand followed by litigation if necessary)All claimsAddresses tortious interference: StreamNow's availability of Aurelius content at lower price points reduced Aurelius's licensing leverage with authorized platforms
38March 8, 2026Marcus Delgado transmits settlement authority recommendation memorandum to Fiona Hartwell and Sir Alistair Pemberton (CEO)Engagement & CounselMarcus Delgado; Fiona Hartwell; Sir Alistair PembertonSettlement Authority Recommendation Memorandum (dated March 8, 2026)Privileged and confidential; recommends opening demand of $41.3M, negotiation floor of $25M plus permanent injunction and full takedown; non-monetary terms include public acknowledgment, content removal, audit rights, undertakings re MDD/Ogilvie; discusses litigation costs through trial and reputational considerationsSettlement strategySuccess fee of 5% on recovery above $20M (capped at $2M) applicable if settlement achieved
39March 10, 2026Client status report transmitted to Fiona Hartwell; draft complaint and draft TRO/PI motion completed with supporting draft declarations (Kowalski, Dr. Frey)Engagement & Counsel / Litigation ReadinessMarcus Delgado; Wendy Schultz; Omar SiddiquiClient Status Report & Recommendation Letter (dated March 10, 2026); Draft Complaint; Draft TRO/PI Motion; Draft Declarations (Kowalski, Frey)Pre-suit preparation complete; recommends proceeding with formal demand on March 14, 2026; draft complaint names StreamNow, MDD, and Ogilvie as defendants; draft TRO/PI motion addresses four Winter factors; draft declarations prepared for Kowalski and Dr. FreyAll claims; Injunctive reliefComplaint asserts 5 causes of action: (1) copyright infringement, (2) contributory infringement, (3) inducement, (4) UCL § 17200, (5) tortious interference
40March 14, 2026Calderwood & Harkness serves formal cease-and-desist / pre-suit demand letter on StreamNow Holdings, Inc. (attn: Tobias Rennert, GC); demand letters also sent to MDD/Ogilvie and all four FAST channel sublicensees (Brindoval, BrightLoop, Velvet Stream, Pacific Lantern)CorrespondenceMarcus Delgado; Wendy Schultz (Calderwood & Harkness); Tobias Rennert (StreamNow GC); Franklin Ogilvie (MDD)Demand Letter — StreamNow (dated March 14, 2026); Demand Letter — MDD/Ogilvie (dated March 14, 2026); Takedown Demands — Brindoval, BrightLoop, Velvet Stream, Pacific Lantern (all dated March 14, 2026)Demands: (1) immediate cessation of all unauthorized reproduction, distribution, and public performance of 217 Aurelius titles, (2) removal from StreamNow platform and sublicensed channels, (3) accounting of all revenues ($38.6M estimated), (4) payment of damages; 30-day response window; states Aurelius will file suit in C.D. Cal. if demands not met; FAST sublicensee takedown demands request 10 business day confirmationAll claimsSent via certified mail and email; identifies Meridian, Iron Compass, and Thornfield franchises specifically; rejects MDD sublicense as unauthorized
41April–May 2026 (target)Settlement negotiation window (30 days from demand letter); StreamNow response expectedCorrespondenceMarcus Delgado; Tobias Rennert; Victoria Langford (Grantham Roth & Pearce LLP)Anticipated — StreamNow response / counterparty correspondenceIf settlement not reached within negotiation window, Aurelius prepared to file complaint in C.D. Cal.; StreamNow's outside counsel is Grantham Roth & Pearce LLP (Victoria Langford, lead partner)Settlement
42June 2026 (contingent)Filing of complaint in U.S. District Court for the Central District of California (Los Angeles Division) if settlement negotiations fail; potential contemporaneous filing of TRO/PI motionLitigation ReadinessMarcus Delgado; Wendy Schultz; Omar SiddiquiDraft Complaint; Draft TRO/PI Motion; Draft Declarations (Kowalski, Frey)Complaint to be filed against StreamNow Holdings, Inc., Meridian Digital Distributors, LLC, and Franklin Ogilvie; seeks actual damages, infringer's profits, statutory damages (alternative), permanent injunction, attorneys' fees, and costsAll claimsFederal subject matter jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1338; venue under 28 U.S.C. § 1400(a); supplemental jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. § 1367

[sheet: Title Summary]

CategoryContent TypeTitle CountEpisode CountRegistration Status — TimelyRegistration Status — LateKey Commercial DataStatutory Damages ExposureNotes
Meridian FranchiseFilm6N/A60Combined global box office: $1.43 billion$900,000All 6 films timely registered; flagship franchise
Iron Compass SeriesTV Series148104 seasons; avg. 9.2 million UK viewers per episode; Aurelius's highest-rated original series$150,000Registered as single series; timely
Thornfield Period Drama CatalogFilm / TV (mixed)12Varies102Winner of 7 BAFTA awards$1,500,00010 timely, 2 late-registered; prestige catalog
Other Feature FilmsFilm124N/A10915General theatrical catalog$16,350,000Includes wide range of genres
Other TV SeriesTV Series74~990 episodes (est.)6311Broadcast and streaming originals$9,450,000Episode counts vary by series
TOTALAll2171,038 episodes (TV only)18928Total content library at issue$32,550,000189 timely × $150,000 = $28,350,000 (statutory damages for timely only); 217 × $150,000 = $32,550,000 (theoretical max if all deemed willful)

[sheet: Revenue Attribution Summary]

Revenue / Damages CategoryAmountSource / MethodologyInfringement PeriodNotes
StreamNow Subscription Revenue Attributable to Aurelius Titles$22,400,000CipherTrace Analytics — refined viewership share model with premium-tier weighting; Aurelius titles = 7.18% of total StreamNow streams; 22-month subscription revenue estimated at $497.6MApril 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026 (22 months)Adjusted from raw viewership share of $35.7M to $22.4M via premium-tier weighting
StreamNow Advertising Revenue (AVOD) Attributable to Aurelius Titles$9,700,000CipherTrace Analytics — ad impression and CPM analysis for Aurelius content on AVOD tierApril 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026 (22 months)
StreamNow Sublicensing Fees from FAST Operators Attributable to Aurelius Titles$6,500,000CipherTrace Analytics — analysis of sublicensing fee allocations to bundles containing Aurelius content; 4 FAST operators (Brindoval, BrightLoop, Velvet Stream, Pacific Lantern)April 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026 (22 months)
Total StreamNow Attributable Revenue (Infringer's Profits Base)$38,600,000Sum of subscription + advertising + sublicensingApril 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026 (22 months)= $22.4M + $9.7M + $6.5M
Aurelius Lost Licensing Revenue (Actual Damages)$14,200,000Hargrove Economic Consulting — fair market value of comparable arm's-length license for 217 titles over 22 months in relevant territories; based on Aurelius's existing licensing agreements with authorized platformsApril 1, 2024 – January 31, 2026 (22 months)
Combined Actual Damages + Infringer's Profits (Unapportioned)$52,800,000Sum of lost licensing + attributable revenue ($14.2M + $38.6M)Subject to apportionment to avoid double-counting
Preliminary Net Recoverable Damages (Hargrove Apportioned Estimate)$41,300,000Hargrove Economic Consulting — actual damages + profits after apportionmentPreferred damages theory; recommended opening demand figure
Statutory Damages Maximum (Alternative)$32,550,00017 U.S.C. § 504(c)(2) — 217 works × $150,000 per work (willful infringement)Available for 189 timely-registered works at enhanced rate; alternative to actual damages

[sheet: Parties & Contacts]

Entity / PersonRoleEntity Type / JurisdictionKey ContactAddressNotes
Aurelius Global Media Group PLCPlaintiff / ClientPublic limited company — England & Wales (Co. No. 08724561)Fiona Hartwell (GC); Sir Alistair Pemberton (CEO)45 Clarewood Place, London W1K 6TH, UKAIM: AGLM; FY2025 Revenue: £1.87B (~$2.36B); Content library: 4,200+ titles; Auditors: Whitmore & Pryce LLP
Aurelius Media Americas, Inc.Plaintiff subsidiary / U.S. operationsCorporation — Delaware (wholly-owned subsidiary of AGMG)Raj Anantharam (SVP); Lena Kowalski (Head of Digital Rights Enforcement)1900 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 2200, Los Angeles, CA 90067Franklin Ogilvie formerly employed here (2017–June 30, 2021)
StreamNow Holdings, Inc.Prospective DefendantCorporation — Delaware (File No. 7291843)Derek Calloway (CEO); Tobias Rennert (GC); Sandra Yee (VP, Content Acquisition)3400 Wilshire Boulevard, Suite 1800, Los Angeles, CA 90010Est. FY2025 Revenue: $312M; majority-owned (~62%) by Pinnacle Ventures Fund III, LP; founded 2019; operates in 14 countries; registered agent: Capitol Registered Agents, Inc., 1209 Orange Street, Wilmington, DE 19801
Meridian Digital Distributors, LLCProspective Defendant / Unauthorized IntermediaryLLC — California (SOS File No. 202115729430)Franklin Ogilvie (sole member/manager)8912 Burton Way, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90211MDD never authorized by Aurelius; formed late 2021 by Ogilvie after separation from Aurelius
Franklin OgilvieProspective Defendant / Former Aurelius EmployeeIndividual—8912 Burton Way, Suite 200, Beverly Hills, CA 90211 (MDD address)Former mid-level licensing manager at AMA (2017–June 30, 2021); separation agreement includes non-compete, non-solicitation, IP prohibition
Pinnacle Ventures Fund III, LPStreamNow majority investorLimited Partnership — Delaware; GP: Pinnacle Ventures Management III, LLCHoward Cheng (Managing Partner)101 California Street, Suite 3500, San Francisco, CA 94111$145M Series C (June 2022); ~62% fully diluted ownership of StreamNow
Brindoval Channel Networks, Inc.FAST channel sublicensee of StreamNowCorporation — Texas—Dallas, TXTakedown demand sent March 14, 2026
BrightLoop Media, LLCFAST channel sublicensee of StreamNowLLC — Florida—Miami, FLTakedown demand sent March 14, 2026
Velvet Stream Partners, LPFAST channel sublicensee of StreamNowLimited Partnership — Ontario, Canada—Toronto, ON, CanadaTakedown demand sent March 14, 2026
Pacific Lantern Digital Pty LtdFAST channel sublicensee of StreamNowProprietary Limited Company — New South Wales, Australia—Sydney, NSW, AustraliaTakedown demand sent March 14, 2026
Calderwood & Harkness LLPOutside IP Counsel (U.S.) for AureliusLLP — New YorkMarcus Delgado (Responsible Partner); Catherine Bloom (Billing Partner); Wendy Schultz (Lead Associate); Omar Siddiqui (Working Associate)1999 Avenue of the Stars, Suite 3100, Los Angeles, CA 90067 (LA); 600 Lexington Avenue, New York, NY 10022 (NY)Matter No. 1017-00003; engaged February 12, 2026
Grantham Roth & Pearce LLPOutside Counsel for StreamNowLLP — CaliforniaVictoria Langford (Partner, IP Litigation); Brian Matsuda (Associate)555 South Flower Street, Suite 4200, Los Angeles, CA 90071
Bexley Marsh Solicitors LLPOutside IP Counsel (UK) for AureliusLLP (solicitors) — England & Wales—14 Bedford Row, London WC1R 4ED, UKEngaged November 18, 2025; recommended U.S. counsel December 5, 2025
CipherTrace Analytics, LLCDigital forensics / technical expertLLC — DelawareDr. Nathan Frey (Director, Digital Media Forensics)2700 Sand Hill Road, Suite 130, Menlo Park, CA 94025Retained February 18, 2026; estimated fee $175,000
Lexington IP Services, Inc.Copyright registration search firmCorporation — District of ColumbiaMarissa Chung (Director of Copyright Research)1625 I Street NW, Suite 400, Washington, DC 20006Search completed January 22, 2026; estimated fee $28,500
Hargrove Economic Consulting Group, LLCDamages / economic expertLLC — CaliforniaDr. Elena Vasquez (Principal, Economics)350 South Grand Avenue, Suite 2800, Los Angeles, CA 90071Retained February 20, 2026; estimated fee $95,000; preliminary net recoverable damages: $41.3M
Fortbridge Specialty Insurance CompanyMedia liability / IP enforcement insurer (Aurelius)Insurance Company — Connecticut (domicile)—280 Trumbull Street, Hartford, CT 06103Policy No. FSI-ML-2024-07821; $25M per occurrence / $50M aggregate; claim tendered March 1, 2026
Calder & Whitfield Insurance Brokers Ltd.Insurance broker (Aurelius)Private limited company — England & Wales—71 Fenchurch Street, London EC3M 4BS, UK
Whitmore & Pryce LLPAuditors (Aurelius)LLP (accounting/audit) — England & Wales—25 Old Broad Street, London EC2N 1HQ, UK