PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL — ATTORNEY-CLIENT COMMUNICATION
Dear Dominic,
Thank you for entrusting Calderwood & Harkness with this matter. I am writing to confirm our engagement, outline our immediate priorities, and identify several items we will need from your team on an expedited basis.
**1. Engagement Confirmation**
As of today, August 19, 2024, Calderwood & Harkness LLP has been formally retained to represent Northgate Telecommunications PLC and its US subsidiary, Northgate Fiber Americas Inc. ("NFA"), in the above-captioned action. The executed engagement letter — covering the scope of representation, billing rates, and preliminary budget — was transmitted to you separately earlier this afternoon.
Our engagement team is as follows:
- **Linda Osei** — Responsible Partner - **Priya Anand** — Billing Partner - **Jeffrey Park** — Lead Associate - **Yuki Nakamura** — Working Associate
For your records, our internal matter number is **1022-00005**. Please reference this number in all correspondence. Our office address is 425 Park Avenue, 33rd Floor, New York, NY 10022.
**2. Case Overview**
We have received and reviewed the Verified Complaint filed by Meridian Infrastructure Partners LLC ("Meridian") on July 15, 2024, in the Supreme Court of the State of New York, New York County, Commercial Division (Index No. 654321/2024). The matter has been assigned to the Honorable Eleanor M. Ricci, Part 49. As you know, the Complaint was served on NFA via the Secretary of State on August 5, 2024.
At a high level, Meridian — a fiber-optic construction contractor — asserts approximately $200 million in claims arising from Northgate's termination for cause of the Master Construction Agreement dated March 15, 2020 (the "MCA"), which governed the design and construction of approximately 18,500 route miles of fiber-optic infrastructure across seven northeastern US states. Meridian is represented by Hargrove, Deluca & Stein LLP, with Thomas Deluca serving as lead partner. We understand that Meridian's private equity sponsor, Ridgepoint Capital Group LP, is funding Meridian's litigation costs, which may inform certain strategic considerations we can discuss on our call.
**3. Immediate Action Item No. 1: Litigation Hold (Highest Priority)**
Our most urgent task is issuing a comprehensive litigation hold notice to all relevant Northgate and NFA personnel. We are preparing a draft hold notice now and aim to issue it **no later than August 21, 2024**.
The hold will cover all documents and electronically stored information ("ESI") related to the MCA, the fiber build-out program, all communications with Meridian and its personnel, the cure notices and termination, and all related internal communications, analyses, and financial records.
To finalize the hold, I need the following from you as soon as possible:
- **Custodian list.** We suggest starting with Renata Voss (VP, US Network Infrastructure), Sean Calloway (Director, Construction Management), Helena Bright (CFO), and yourself, but we will need to identify additional project team members, field supervisors, and any other personnel who had substantive involvement in or oversight of the Meridian relationship. Please send us a comprehensive list at your earliest convenience. - **IT systems and repositories.** Please confirm the email platforms, document management systems, project management tools (e.g., Glenrock Health IT, Harborline Software, or similar), shared drives, and any other repositories used by NFA in connection with the fiber build-out program. This will enable us to ensure preservation is comprehensive and defensible.
**In the interim, I must emphasize that no documents — whether in hard copy or electronic form — should be destroyed, deleted, or altered.** Please ensure that any auto-deletion or retention policies that might affect relevant materials are suspended immediately. If you have any concern that routine IT processes could result in the loss of data before we issue the formal hold, please let me know right away so we can address it.
**4. Immediate Action Item No. 2: Answer Deadline**
Under CPLR § 320(a), because service was effected on NFA via the Secretary of State on August 5, 2024, NFA must serve its answer within 30 days — which yields a deadline of **September 4, 2024**. (I note that Labor Day falls on September 2 and September 3 is the first business day thereafter; we are verifying the precise computation to confirm whether September 3 or September 4 is the operative date, but in either event we are working to the earlier date.)
This is a tight timeline, and we are beginning our drafting work immediately. Our current recommendation is to file an **Answer with Affirmative Defenses and Counterclaims** rather than pursue a pre-answer motion to dismiss. While there may be grounds to challenge certain of Meridian's claims, we believe the stronger strategic posture is to preserve Northgate's counterclaim rights and avoid the delay and uncertainty associated with a motion that, if unsuccessful, would push our answer deadline back without material benefit. We anticipate asserting counterclaims for:
- Liquidated damages for schedule delays under MCA § 9.1; - Excess completion costs arising from the replacement contract with Crestline Construction Group; and - Remediation costs for defective and non-conforming work.
We will discuss this in greater detail once we complete our initial case assessment, but I would like to schedule a call within the **next one to two days** to walk through answer and counterclaim strategy and ensure alignment with Northgate's leadership, including Sir Malcolm Ashford. Please let me know your availability.
**5. Immediate Action Item No. 3: Initial Case Assessment**
We are preparing a preliminary case assessment memorandum that will analyze the strengths and weaknesses of each of Meridian's four claims and evaluate Northgate's potential defenses and counterclaims. We expect to deliver this memo to you by approximately **August 26, 2024**.
Our initial review suggests that Northgate has a strong defense. The core theory is straightforward: the termination was justified under MCA § 14.1 because Meridian committed material breach through (a) persistent and severe schedule delays, with milestones late by 22 to over 134 days; (b) substandard workmanship, as evidenced by 287 non-conformance reports, including 43 classified as critical; and (c) failure to cure after proper notice. The assessment will also include a detailed analysis of the consequential damages waiver in MCA § 20.1, which we believe provides a strong defense to Meridian's lost-profits and reputational-harm claims, as well as an analysis of the liquidated damages provisions under MCA § 9.1 that will be integral to our counterclaim strategy.
To support this work, we will need the following documents as soon as practicable:
1. The fully executed Master Construction Agreement and all exhibits (including Exhibit B — milestone schedule and values); 2. All Change Orders, both formal and any informal directives; 3. Cure Notice Nos. 1 and 2 and all responses received from Meridian; 4. The Notice of Termination for Cause dated April 1, 2024; 5. Meridian's Corrective Action Plan and Northgate's rejection letter; 6. The full set of 287 non-conformance reports; 7. Monthly QA reports; 8. Payment applications and payment records; 9. The Crestline Construction Group replacement contract dated June 10, 2024; and 10. Any prior correspondence between Northgate/NFA and Meridian's counsel (Hargrove, Deluca & Stein).
If it is easier to arrange a document room or secure file transfer, Jeffrey Park will coordinate logistics with your team.
**6. Immediate Action Item No. 4: Insurance Notifications**
We strongly recommend that Northgate promptly notify its insurance carriers of Meridian's claims. Timely notice is a condition to coverage under most policies, and any delay could jeopardize Northgate's rights. The relevant policies we have identified are:
- **D&O Policy:** Albion Specialty Insurance Ltd., Policy No. ALB-DO-2023-4782 - **CGL Policy:** Keystone National Insurance Company, Policy No. KNIC-CGL-2022-99301
Please let me know whether you have already provided notice to either carrier. If not, we can prepare or review the notice letters for you. Based on prior experience with these carriers, we anticipate they may retain coverage counsel — likely Pemberton Fox LLP — and we will coordinate with them as needed.
Separately, I want to flag the **performance bond** issued by Ironclad Surety Group Inc. (Bond No. ISG-2020-NE-04417, penal sum $120 million). We understand Meridian filed a demand on the bond on April 15, 2024. We will reach out to Ironclad's claims contact, Patricia Dwyer, to tender defense of that demand and discuss Ironclad's position, including any willingness to contribute to defense costs. Please let me know if there have been any communications with Ironclad to date.
**7. Next Steps**
To summarize our immediate priorities and scheduling needs:
- **Litigation hold** — We will circulate a draft hold notice for your review by August 20; target issuance by August 21. Please send the custodian list and IT systems information at your earliest opportunity. - **Strategy call** — Please let us know your availability in the next one to two days for a call to walk through the factual chronology in detail, discuss key custodians and document sources, align on answer and counterclaim strategy, and discuss any settlement overtures or communications with Meridian to date. We would welcome the participation of Renata Voss and Sean Calloway if appropriate. - **Document collection** — Please begin assembling the items listed in Section 5 above. - **Insurance notice** — Please confirm the status of carrier notifications. - **Conflict check** — Our conflict check memo is being finalized and we expect to clear it shortly.
Looking ahead, once the initial case assessment is complete, we will turn to expert retention — specifically, a construction and delay expert and a damages expert — and will discuss candidates and timing with you in the coming weeks.
For urgent matters, I can be reached at any time:
- **Direct:** (212) 555-4180 - **Cell:** (917) 555-6923
Dominic, based on our initial review of the record — particularly the documented history of schedule failures, the volume and severity of the non-conformance reports, and the cure process — I am confident in the strength of Northgate's defense position. We have a strong story to tell, and we intend to tell it aggressively. Thank you for your confidence in Calderwood & Harkness. The full team is mobilized and ready to move quickly.
I look forward to connecting with you in the next day or two.
Warm regards,
**Linda Osei** Partner, Litigation Calderwood & Harkness LLP 425 Park Avenue, 33rd Floor New York, NY 10022 Direct: (212) 555-4180 Cell: (917) 555-6923 Email: losei@calderwoodharkness.com
---
*This email and any attachments are privileged and confidential and are intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. This communication is protected by the attorney-client privilege and/or work product doctrine. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify the sender immediately and delete this message. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, or distribution is prohibited.*