1031-00004 · Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC · Closing Opinions

opinion-letter-mezzanine-lender.docx DOCUMENT Real Estate

2 / 80 ← → ✕

Contract analysis Extract to table

CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP Counselors at Law

One Liberty Plaza, 55th Floor New York, New York 10006

Telephone: (212) 558-4000 Facsimile: (212) 558-3588 www.calderwoodharkness.com

June 15, 2025

Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP 9 West 57th Street, Suite 4200 New York, New York 10019

Attention: Diane Castellano, Managing Partner

Victor Salinas, Senior Vice President, Originations

Re: Mezzanine Loan in the principal amount of $200,000,000 from Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, as Mezzanine Lender, to Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, as Mezzanine Borrower — Hudson Yards West Project, 450 West 34th Street, New York, New York 10001

Ladies and Gentlemen:

I. Introduction

We have acted as counsel to Metropolitan Transit Development Corp. ("MTDC"), Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC (the "Mezzanine Borrower" or "HYW Mezzanine"), and Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC ("HYW Mortgage") in connection with the mezzanine loan in the original principal amount of Two Hundred Million Dollars ($200,000,000) (the "Mezzanine Loan") made by Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP (the "Mezzanine Lender" or "Granite Peak") to the Mezzanine Borrower pursuant to the Mezzanine Loan Agreement (as defined below). This opinion letter is delivered to you pursuant to Section 9.1(b)(vi) of the Mezzanine Loan Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025 (the "Closing Date"), between the Mezzanine Borrower and the Mezzanine Lender. This opinion is rendered in connection with the closing of the Mezzanine Loan on the date hereof.

This matter is being handled by this Firm under C&H Matter No. 1031-00004.

II. Defined Terms and Mezzanine Loan Documents Identified

As used in this opinion letter, the term "Mezzanine Loan Documents" means, collectively, the following documents, agreements, and instruments executed and delivered in connection with the Mezzanine Loan:

(a) The Mezzanine Loan Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, by and between the Mezzanine Borrower and the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Loan Agreement");

(b) The Mezzanine Promissory Note, dated as of June 15, 2025, in the original principal amount of $200,000,000, made by the Mezzanine Borrower payable to the order of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Promissory Note");

(c) The Pledge and Security Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, made by the Mezzanine Borrower in favor of the Mezzanine Lender, pursuant to which the Mezzanine Borrower has pledged, assigned, and granted a security interest in one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC (the "Pledged Interests") to the Mezzanine Lender as collateral for the Mezzanine Loan (the "Pledge and Security Agreement");

(d) The Guaranty of Recourse Obligations (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, made by MTDC for the benefit of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Guaranty");

(e) The Environmental Indemnity Agreement (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, made by the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC for the benefit of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Environmental Indemnity Agreement");

(f) The Cash Management Agreement (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, by and among the Mezzanine Borrower, the Mezzanine Lender, and the depository bank party thereto (the "Cash Management Agreement");

(g) The Intercreditor Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, by and among Ironclad National Bank, N.A., as Senior Lender and Administrative Agent (the "Senior Lender"), and Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, as Mezzanine Lender, and acknowledged and agreed to by the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, to the extent the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC are parties thereto (the "Intercreditor Agreement"); and

(h) UCC-1 Financing Statements to be filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware in connection with the perfection of the security interest in the Pledged Interests (the "UCC Financing Statements").

Capitalized terms used but not otherwise defined in this opinion letter shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the Mezzanine Loan Agreement.

III. Documents and Records Examined

In connection with the rendering of the opinions set forth herein, we have examined originals or copies, certified or otherwise identified to our satisfaction, of the following documents, instruments, certificates, and records:

(a) Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents listed in Section II above, in the form in which each such document has been executed and delivered on the Closing Date;

(b) The Certificate of Formation of Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, as filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on March 12, 2024, together with all amendments thereto (if any) as reflected in the records of the Delaware Secretary of State;

(c) The Limited Liability Company Agreement of Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, dated as of March 15, 2024, together with all amendments, supplements, and restatements thereof through the date hereof (collectively, the "HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement");

(d) The Certificate of Formation of Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, as filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on March 12, 2024, together with all amendments thereto (if any) as reflected in the records of the Delaware Secretary of State;

(e) The Limited Liability Company Agreement of Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, dated as of March 15, 2024, together with all amendments, supplements, and restatements thereof through the date hereof (collectively, the "HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement");

(f) A Certificate of Good Standing for Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware, dated June 11, 2025, and a Certificate of Good Standing (or equivalent certificate of authority) for Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of New York, dated June 10, 2025, each dated within five (5) business days of the date hereof;

(g) A Certificate of Good Standing for Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware, dated June 11, 2025, and a Certificate of Good Standing (or equivalent certificate of authority) for Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of New York, dated June 10, 2025, each dated within five (5) business days of the date hereof;

(h) The enabling legislation pursuant to which MTDC was created, the bylaws of MTDC, and certain resolutions of the Board of Directors of MTDC (Margaret Kowalski, Chair), including, without limitation, the resolution adopted by the Board of Directors of MTDC on May 28, 2025, authorizing the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents and authorizing the execution, delivery, and performance by MTDC of the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement;

(i) Officer's certificates of each of the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, dated as of the Closing Date, delivered in connection with the closing of the Mezzanine Loan, certifying, among other things, the organizational documents, incumbency of officers and authorized signatories, and the accuracy of certain factual representations made in connection with the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents (collectively, the "Officer's Certificates");

(j) The results of searches of Uniform Commercial Code financing statement filings conducted on or about June 12, 2025, against Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC as debtor in the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware and in the office of the filing officer of the State of New York, with respect to HYW Mezzanine and the Pledged Interests (collectively, the "UCC Lien Search Results"); and

(k) Such other documents, instruments, certificates, records, and matters of law as this Firm has deemed necessary or appropriate for the purposes of the opinions expressed herein.

We have not independently investigated or verified any of the factual matters set forth in the Officer's Certificates or in any other certificate or document delivered to us in connection with this opinion, and no inference as to our knowledge of any such factual matters should be drawn from our representation of the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC or from the rendering of the opinions set forth below.

IV. Assumptions

In rendering the opinions set forth in this letter, we have, with your consent, assumed the following:

(a) All signatures on documents and instruments (other than the signatures of authorized representatives of the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC, as to which we express the opinions set forth below) are genuine, and all natural persons who have signed any document or instrument reviewed by us have had the legal capacity to execute such document or instrument at the time of such execution.

(b) All documents submitted to us as originals are authentic, complete, and accurate, and all documents submitted to us as copies conform to the originals thereof, which originals are themselves authentic, complete, and accurate.

(c) The Mezzanine Lender is a limited partnership duly organized, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of its jurisdiction of formation, and has full limited partnership power and authority to enter into, execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which it is a party.

(d) Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of the Mezzanine Lender, enforceable against the Mezzanine Lender in accordance with its respective terms.

(e) All factual matters, statements, and representations set forth in the Officer's Certificates and in all other certificates, documents, and instruments reviewed by us in connection with this opinion letter are true, correct, and complete as of the date hereof, and no material facts have been withheld from us.

(f) Except as specifically opined upon herein with respect to the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents has been duly authorized by all necessary action on the part of, and has been duly executed and delivered by, each party thereto (other than the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC).

(g) There has been no mutual mistake of fact or misunderstanding, fraud, duress, or undue influence with respect to any of the Mezzanine Loan Documents or the transactions contemplated thereby, and each Mezzanine Loan Document accurately reflects the complete agreement of the parties thereto with respect to the subject matter thereof.

(h) The conduct of all parties to the Mezzanine Loan Documents has complied and will comply with any requirement of good faith, fair dealing, and conscionability imposed by applicable law, and no party has engaged or will engage in any conduct that would render any provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents unenforceable.

(i) The Mezzanine Lender has acted and will act in good faith, without notice of any defense against the enforcement of any rights created by the Mezzanine Loan Documents, and in compliance with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations in connection with the making and administration of the Mezzanine Loan.

(j) No event has occurred and no condition exists that would make any of the factual representations or warranties made by any party in connection with the Mezzanine Loan Documents untrue or inaccurate in any material respect.

V. Opinions

Based upon the foregoing and subject to the assumptions set forth in Section IV above and the qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth in Section VI below, and having regard for such legal considerations as we deem relevant, we are of the opinion that:

Opinion 1 — Organization and Existence of Mezzanine Borrower (HYW Mezzanine)

Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC is a limited liability company duly formed, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of the State of Delaware. HYW Mezzanine is duly qualified to transact business and is in good standing as a foreign limited liability company in the State of New York. HYW Mezzanine has all requisite limited liability company power and authority to own, hold, and dispose of its assets, including, without limitation, one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, to carry on its business as presently conducted, and to execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which it is a party.

Opinion 2 — Organization and Existence of HYW Mortgage (as Confirmation of Pledged Entity)

Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC is a limited liability company duly formed, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of the State of Delaware. HYW Mortgage is duly qualified to transact business and is in good standing as a foreign limited liability company in the State of New York. The membership interests in HYW Mortgage that are pledged under the Pledge and Security Agreement (i.e., one hundred percent (100%) of the issued and outstanding membership interests in HYW Mortgage) have been duly authorized and validly issued in accordance with the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement and the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act (6 Del. C. § 18-101 et seq.). Such membership interests are fully paid and non-assessable to the extent that the concepts of "fully paid" and "non-assessable" are applicable to limited liability company interests under the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act. The Pledged Interests are owned of record by the Mezzanine Borrower, and, based solely on our review of the UCC Lien Search Results, the Officer's Certificates, and the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement, such interests are free and clear of all liens, security interests, encumbrances, pledges, charges, claims, and adverse claims of any kind whatsoever, other than the lien and security interest created in favor of the Mezzanine Lender by the Pledge and Security Agreement.

Opinion 3 — Authorization of MTDC as Guarantor

Metropolitan Transit Development Corp. is a government instrumentality duly created and validly existing under the laws of the State of Illinois, pursuant to the enabling legislation identified in Section III(h) above. MTDC has full power and authority under its enabling legislation and organizational documents to execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement. The execution, delivery, and performance by MTDC of the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement have been duly authorized by all requisite action on the part of MTDC, including, without limitation, the adoption of a resolution by the Board of Directors of MTDC (Margaret Kowalski, Chair), at a duly called and held meeting of the Board at which a quorum was present, authorizing MTDC to enter into and perform its obligations under the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement and authorizing the officers of MTDC named therein to execute and deliver such documents on behalf of MTDC.

Opinion 4 — Due Authorization and Execution

Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower is a party has been duly authorized by all necessary limited liability company action on the part of the Mezzanine Borrower, in accordance with the HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement and the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, and has been duly executed and delivered by the Mezzanine Borrower. Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which MTDC is a party has been duly authorized by all necessary corporate or governmental action on the part of MTDC, in accordance with the enabling legislation, bylaws, and applicable resolutions of the Board of Directors of MTDC, and has been duly executed and delivered by MTDC. No further action, approval, or consent on the part of the Mezzanine Borrower, its members or managers, or MTDC, its Board of Directors, officers, or any other person or body, is required to authorize the execution, delivery, and performance of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower and/or MTDC is a party.

Opinion 5 — Enforceability

Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower is a party constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of the Mezzanine Borrower, enforceable against the Mezzanine Borrower in accordance with its respective terms. Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which MTDC is a party constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of MTDC, enforceable against MTDC in accordance with its respective terms. The foregoing opinions regarding enforceability are subject, in each case, to the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) below.

Opinion 6 — Security Interest in Pledged Membership Interests

(a) The Pledge and Security Agreement is effective to create in favor of the Mezzanine Lender a valid security interest, within the meaning of Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code as in effect in the State of New York (the "NY UCC"), in the Pledged Interests (i.e., one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC held by the Mezzanine Borrower) and in all proceeds (as defined in Section 9-102(a)(64) of the NY UCC) thereof, as security for the obligations of the Mezzanine Borrower described in the Pledge and Security Agreement and the other Mezzanine Loan Documents.

(b) The Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles" within the meaning of Section 9-102(a)(42) of the NY UCC. We note that, if the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement were amended to "opt in" to Article 8 of the NY UCC, and if certificates representing the Pledged Interests were issued, the Pledged Interests (or portions thereof) might instead constitute "certificated securities" within the meaning of Section 8-102(a)(4) of the NY UCC. Based on our review of the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement and the Officer's Certificates delivered to us, the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement does not currently provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are securities governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, and no certificates have been issued to represent such interests.

(c) Upon the filing of UCC-1 financing statements naming the Mezzanine Borrower as debtor and the Mezzanine Lender as secured party, in proper form for filing, with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware (HYW Mezzanine being organized under the laws of the State of Delaware, and the State of Delaware being the jurisdiction in which filings are required to be made under Section 9-301(1) of the NY UCC to perfect a security interest in general intangibles of a debtor organized in that jurisdiction), the Mezzanine Lender's security interest in the Pledged Interests (to the extent the Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles" within the meaning of the NY UCC) will be perfected. If, at any time hereafter, the Pledged Interests are evidenced by certificates and the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement is amended to provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are securities governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, then perfection of the security interest in the Pledged Interests may also be accomplished or maintained by delivery of such certificates to the Mezzanine Lender (or its agent), endorsed in blank or accompanied by duly executed undated instruments of transfer in blank, in accordance with Article 8 of the NY UCC.

(d) Based solely on our review of the UCC Lien Search Results obtained from the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on or about June 12, 2025, no prior UCC financing statement naming Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC as debtor and covering or purporting to cover the Pledged Interests has been filed in the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware. Accordingly, upon the filing of the UCC Financing Statements referenced herein in the office of the Delaware Secretary of State, the Mezzanine Lender's security interest in the Pledged Interests (to the extent the Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles") will have first priority over any security interest that may be perfected by a financing statement filed subsequently in such office covering the same collateral, subject in all cases to the qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth in Section VI below.

Opinion 7 — No Conflicts

The execution, delivery, and performance by the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which each is a party, and the consummation of the transactions contemplated thereby, including, without limitation, the pledge and grant of a security interest in the Pledged Interests to the Mezzanine Lender, do not and will not:

(a) Violate or conflict with (i) the Certificate of Formation or the HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement of the Mezzanine Borrower, (ii) the Certificate of Formation or the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement of HYW Mortgage, or (iii) the enabling legislation, bylaws, or other organizational documents of MTDC;

(b) Violate or conflict with any law, statute, rule, or regulation of the State of New York or the United States of America applicable to the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC that, in the experience of this Firm, is typically applicable to transactions of the type contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents. We note that we do not express any opinion on regulatory matters specific to government instrumentalities of the State of Illinois except to the extent expressly covered in Opinion 3 above based on our review of the enabling legislation and organizational documents of MTDC;

(c) Result in a breach of, or constitute a default (or an event that, with the giving of notice, the lapse of time, or both, would constitute a default) under, any agreement, indenture, mortgage, deed of trust, or other instrument listed on the Officer's Certificates delivered to this Firm, to which the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC is a party or by which any of their respective properties or assets may be bound or affected; or

(d) Result in the creation or imposition of any lien, charge, pledge, security interest, encumbrance, or other restriction upon the Pledged Interests or any other property or assets of the Mezzanine Borrower, other than (i) the lien and security interest created by the Pledge and Security Agreement in favor of the Mezzanine Lender, and (ii) any filing of UCC financing statements as referenced herein and contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents.

Opinion 8 — No Consents or Approvals

No consent, approval, authorization, order, registration, qualification, designation, declaration, or filing with or by any governmental authority or agency of the State of New York or any agency or instrumentality of the United States of America is required for the valid execution, delivery, and performance by the Mezzanine Borrower or MTDC of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which each is a party, or for the validity or enforceability of the Mezzanine Loan Documents, except: (i) such consents, approvals, authorizations, orders, registrations, qualifications, or filings as have been obtained or made on or prior to the date hereof and remain in full force and effect as of the date hereof; and (ii) the filing of UCC financing statements (and, in due course, continuation statements) with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware in connection with the perfection and maintenance of the security interest in the Pledged Interests granted pursuant to the Pledge and Security Agreement.

Opinion 9 — Choice of Law

Each Mezzanine Loan Document that by its terms is to be governed by the laws of the State of New York contains a valid and effective choice of the laws of the State of New York as the governing law of such Mezzanine Loan Document. Pursuant to Section 5-1401 of the New York General Obligations Law, which provides that a choice of New York law is effective where the parties have agreed that the law of the State of New York shall govern and the aggregate consideration payable under the contract exceeds $250,000, a court of the State of New York or a federal court sitting in the State of New York would give effect to such choice-of-law provisions, inasmuch as the principal amount of the Mezzanine Loan ($200,000,000) exceeds the statutory threshold set forth in N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 5-1401. The foregoing opinion is subject to the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) below. We express no opinion as to the enforceability of any choice-of-law provision contained in any Mezzanine Loan Document that by its terms is to be governed by the law of a jurisdiction other than the State of New York, and we express no opinion as to whether a court of a jurisdiction other than New York would give effect to such choice-of-law provisions.

Opinion 10 — Usury

The charging, collection, and receipt of interest at the fixed rate of 11.50% per annum as provided in the Mezzanine Promissory Note and the Mezzanine Loan Agreement does not violate the usury laws of the State of New York. In rendering this opinion, we have taken into account that the original principal amount of the Mezzanine Loan is $200,000,000, which exceeds the threshold of $2,500,000 set forth in Section 5-501(6)(b) of the New York General Obligations Law, and accordingly, the maximum rate of interest provisions set forth in Section 5-501(1) and (2) of the New York General Obligations Law and Section 14-a(1) of the New York Banking Law are not applicable to the Mezzanine Loan. We note that this opinion is limited to the usury laws of the State of New York and does not address usury or interest rate limitations under the laws of any other jurisdiction. We further note that we express no opinion as to whether any fees, charges, or other amounts payable under the Mezzanine Loan Documents, when aggregated with interest, would cause the effective rate of return to the Mezzanine Lender to exceed any applicable usury limit, as we have assumed that all such fees and charges constitute bona fide fees for services or reimbursements and are not disguised interest.

VI. Qualifications, Limitations, and Exceptions

A. Enforceability Qualifications

The opinions expressed in this letter with respect to the enforceability of the Mezzanine Loan Documents are subject to the following qualifications (collectively, the "Enforceability Qualifications"):

(i) The effect of applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization, moratorium, receivership, conservatorship, fraudulent conveyance, fraudulent transfer, and other similar laws now or hereafter in effect affecting the enforcement of creditors' rights and remedies generally, including, without limitation, the effect of statutory and other laws regarding preferential transfers and fraudulent conveyances.

(ii) The effect of general principles of equity (regardless of whether enforcement is sought in a proceeding in equity or at law), including, without limitation, concepts of materiality, reasonableness, good faith, and fair dealing, and the possible unavailability of specific performance, injunctive relief, or other equitable remedies.

(iii) The effect of applicable public policy on the enforceability of provisions of the Mezzanine Loan Documents that purport to indemnify, hold harmless, or exculpate a party against or from liability for its own action or inaction, to the extent that such action or inaction involves negligence, gross negligence, bad faith, willful misconduct, or violation of applicable law.

(iv) The possible unenforceability, under certain circumstances, of provisions of the Mezzanine Loan Documents that impose penalties, forfeitures, increased interest rates (including default interest), or late charges upon delinquency in payment or the occurrence of a default, to the extent that such provisions are deemed to constitute unenforceable liquidated damages, penalties, or forfeitures under applicable law.

(v) Limitations imposed by applicable law on the enforceability of waivers, releases, and exculpation clauses, including, without limitation, waivers of rights to a trial by jury, waivers of service of process requirements, waivers of rights of redemption, waivers of appraisement or valuation rights, waivers of stay or extension laws, or waivers of any other statutory or constitutional rights that may not be waived as a matter of applicable law.

B. Other Qualifications, Limitations, and Exceptions

The opinions expressed in this letter are further subject to the following qualifications, limitations, and exceptions:

(i) The opinions expressed herein are limited to the laws of the State of New York, the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act (6 Del. C. § 18-101 et seq.), the Uniform Commercial Code as in effect in the State of New York and the State of Delaware, and the federal laws of the United States of America, in each case as in effect on the date hereof. We express no opinion as to the laws of any other jurisdiction, including, without limitation, the laws of the State of Illinois, except to the extent that MTDC's due authorization is confirmed in Opinion 3 above based on our review of its enabling legislation, organizational documents, and resolutions of its Board of Directors.

(ii) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to the financial or economic terms of the Mezzanine Loan, the adequacy or fairness of the consideration received by any party in connection with the Mezzanine Loan Documents, or the commercial reasonableness of any term or provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents.

(iii) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to Title 11 of the United States Code (the "Bankruptcy Code") or any state insolvency law or any similar law affecting the rights and remedies of creditors, except as specifically referenced in the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) above.

(iv) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to federal or state securities laws (including the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended), the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended ("ERISA"), tax law (including federal, state, and local tax law), environmental law (including the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act), antitrust law, criminal law, intellectual property law, healthcare law, pension law, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, anti-money laundering laws (including the USA PATRIOT Act), sanctions laws (including regulations administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control), or the laws, rules, or regulations of any regulatory authority applicable specifically to government instrumentalities, public benefit corporations, or municipal entities.

(v) No opinion is expressed herein as to the effect of fraudulent conveyance, fraudulent transfer, or preference laws (whether arising under federal bankruptcy law or applicable state law) on the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents, including, without limitation, the enforceability of the Mezzanine Guaranty or the pledge of the Pledged Interests under the Pledge and Security Agreement.

(vi) No opinion is expressed herein regarding the enforceability of any provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents requiring the payment of attorneys' fees, costs of collection, or expenses of enforcement, except to the extent permitted by applicable law and the discretion of the court before which enforcement is sought.

(vii) No opinion is expressed herein as to the priority of the security interest created by the Pledge and Security Agreement vis-à-vis (A) any purchase money security interest that may arise under applicable law, (B) any interest arising under federal law (including any tax lien arising under the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended), (C) any interest arising by operation of law (including, without limitation, any mechanics' lien, materialmen's lien, or statutory lien), or (D) any interest of a person who obtains control (as defined in Article 8 or Article 9 of the NY UCC, as applicable) of the Pledged Interests.

(viii) The opinions expressed herein regarding the Pledged Interests assume that the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement has not been amended to "opt in" to Article 8 of the NY UCC, and that no certificates representing the membership interests in HYW Mortgage have been issued, unless the Officer's Certificates expressly confirm otherwise. The characterization of the Pledged Interests as "general intangibles" within the meaning of the NY UCC is based upon that assumption. If the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement is hereafter amended to provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are "securities" governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, or if certificates representing such interests are hereafter issued, the method of perfection applicable to the security interest in the Pledged Interests may change, and additional action may be required by the Mezzanine Lender to maintain perfection and priority of its security interest therein.

VII. Reliance and Benefit

This opinion letter is furnished solely for the benefit of Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, in its capacity as Mezzanine Lender, and its successors and permitted assigns under the Mezzanine Loan Agreement (including any future holder of the Mezzanine Loan, any assignee or transferee of any interest in the Mezzanine Loan, and any participant in the Mezzanine Loan), in connection with the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents. This opinion letter may not be relied upon by any other person or entity, or for any purpose other than in connection with the Mezzanine Loan, without the prior written consent of Calderwood & Harkness LLP.

This opinion letter is rendered as of the date hereof, and we express no opinion as to circumstances, events, or developments occurring after the date hereof. We undertake no obligation, and hereby disclaim any obligation, to advise you of any change in applicable law, or to update, revise, or supplement this opinion letter, to reflect any facts or circumstances that may hereafter come to our attention or any changes in law (whether by legislative action, judicial decision, or otherwise) that may hereafter occur, even if such changes would affect the opinions expressed herein.

Notwithstanding the foregoing, we hereby consent to the delivery of a copy of this opinion letter to (i) Voss Richter & Baines LLP, in its capacity as counsel to the Mezzanine Lender, and (ii) Pinnacle Ratings Group, in connection with any rating of the Mezzanine Loan or any securities backed, in whole or in part, by the Mezzanine Loan. Each such recipient may rely on this opinion letter as if it were an addressee hereof, subject to the same terms, conditions, assumptions, qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth herein.

Very truly yours,

CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP

By: ________

Name: Douglas Fairchild

Title: Partner

One Liberty Plaza, 55th Floor New York, New York 10006

C&H Matter No. 1031-00004

CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP Counselors at Law
One Liberty Plaza, 55th Floor New York, New York 10006
Telephone: (212) 558-4000 Facsimile: (212) 558-3588 www.calderwoodharkness.com
June 15, 2025
Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP 9 West 57th Street, Suite 4200 New York, New York 10019
Attention: Diane Castellano, Managing Partner
Victor Salinas, Senior Vice President, Originations
Re: Mezzanine Loan in the principal amount of $200,000,000 from Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, as Mezzanine Lender, to Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, as Mezzanine Borrower — Hudson Yards West Project, 450 West 34th Street, New York, New York 10001
Ladies and Gentlemen:
I. Introduction
We have acted as counsel to Metropolitan Transit Development Corp. ("MTDC"), Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC (the "Mezzanine Borrower" or "HYW Mezzanine"), and Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC ("HYW Mortgage") in connection with the mezzanine loan in the original principal amount of Two Hundred Million Dollars ($200,000,000) (the "Mezzanine Loan") made by Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP (the "Mezzanine Lender" or "Granite Peak") to the Mezzanine Borrower pursuant to the Mezzanine Loan Agreement (as defined below). This opinion letter is delivered to you pursuant to Section 9.1(b)(vi) of the Mezzanine Loan Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025 (the "Closing Date"), between the Mezzanine Borrower and the Mezzanine Lender. This opinion is rendered in connection with the closing of the Mezzanine Loan on the date hereof.
This matter is being handled by this Firm under C&H Matter No. 1031-00004.
II. Defined Terms and Mezzanine Loan Documents Identified
As used in this opinion letter, the term "Mezzanine Loan Documents" means, collectively, the following documents, agreements, and instruments executed and delivered in connection with the Mezzanine Loan:
(a) The Mezzanine Loan Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, by and between the Mezzanine Borrower and the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Loan Agreement");
(b) The Mezzanine Promissory Note, dated as of June 15, 2025, in the original principal amount of $200,000,000, made by the Mezzanine Borrower payable to the order of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Promissory Note");
(c) The Pledge and Security Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, made by the Mezzanine Borrower in favor of the Mezzanine Lender, pursuant to which the Mezzanine Borrower has pledged, assigned, and granted a security interest in one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC (the "Pledged Interests") to the Mezzanine Lender as collateral for the Mezzanine Loan (the "Pledge and Security Agreement");
(d) The Guaranty of Recourse Obligations (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, made by MTDC for the benefit of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Mezzanine Guaranty");
(e) The Environmental Indemnity Agreement (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, made by the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC for the benefit of the Mezzanine Lender (the "Environmental Indemnity Agreement");
(f) The Cash Management Agreement (Mezzanine), dated as of June 15, 2025, by and among the Mezzanine Borrower, the Mezzanine Lender, and the depository bank party thereto (the "Cash Management Agreement");
(g) The Intercreditor Agreement, dated as of June 15, 2025, by and among Ironclad National Bank, N.A., as Senior Lender and Administrative Agent (the "Senior Lender"), and Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, as Mezzanine Lender, and acknowledged and agreed to by the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, to the extent the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC are parties thereto (the "Intercreditor Agreement"); and
(h) UCC-1 Financing Statements to be filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware in connection with the perfection of the security interest in the Pledged Interests (the "UCC Financing Statements").
Capitalized terms used but not otherwise defined in this opinion letter shall have the meanings ascribed to such terms in the Mezzanine Loan Agreement.
III. Documents and Records Examined
In connection with the rendering of the opinions set forth herein, we have examined originals or copies, certified or otherwise identified to our satisfaction, of the following documents, instruments, certificates, and records:
(a) Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents listed in Section II above, in the form in which each such document has been executed and delivered on the Closing Date;
(b) The Certificate of Formation of Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, as filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on March 12, 2024, together with all amendments thereto (if any) as reflected in the records of the Delaware Secretary of State;
(c) The Limited Liability Company Agreement of Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC, dated as of March 15, 2024, together with all amendments, supplements, and restatements thereof through the date hereof (collectively, the "HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement");
(d) The Certificate of Formation of Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, as filed with the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on March 12, 2024, together with all amendments thereto (if any) as reflected in the records of the Delaware Secretary of State;
(e) The Limited Liability Company Agreement of Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, dated as of March 15, 2024, together with all amendments, supplements, and restatements thereof through the date hereof (collectively, the "HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement");
(f) A Certificate of Good Standing for Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware, dated June 11, 2025, and a Certificate of Good Standing (or equivalent certificate of authority) for Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of New York, dated June 10, 2025, each dated within five (5) business days of the date hereof;
(g) A Certificate of Good Standing for Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware, dated June 11, 2025, and a Certificate of Good Standing (or equivalent certificate of authority) for Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC issued by the Secretary of State of the State of New York, dated June 10, 2025, each dated within five (5) business days of the date hereof;
(h) The enabling legislation pursuant to which MTDC was created, the bylaws of MTDC, and certain resolutions of the Board of Directors of MTDC (Margaret Kowalski, Chair), including, without limitation, the resolution adopted by the Board of Directors of MTDC on May 28, 2025, authorizing the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents and authorizing the execution, delivery, and performance by MTDC of the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement;
(i) Officer's certificates of each of the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, dated as of the Closing Date, delivered in connection with the closing of the Mezzanine Loan, certifying, among other things, the organizational documents, incumbency of officers and authorized signatories, and the accuracy of certain factual representations made in connection with the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents (collectively, the "Officer's Certificates");
(j) The results of searches of Uniform Commercial Code financing statement filings conducted on or about June 12, 2025, against Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC as debtor in the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware and in the office of the filing officer of the State of New York, with respect to HYW Mezzanine and the Pledged Interests (collectively, the "UCC Lien Search Results"); and
(k) Such other documents, instruments, certificates, records, and matters of law as this Firm has deemed necessary or appropriate for the purposes of the opinions expressed herein.
We have not independently investigated or verified any of the factual matters set forth in the Officer's Certificates or in any other certificate or document delivered to us in connection with this opinion, and no inference as to our knowledge of any such factual matters should be drawn from our representation of the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC or from the rendering of the opinions set forth below.
IV. Assumptions
In rendering the opinions set forth in this letter, we have, with your consent, assumed the following:
(a) All signatures on documents and instruments (other than the signatures of authorized representatives of the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC, as to which we express the opinions set forth below) are genuine, and all natural persons who have signed any document or instrument reviewed by us have had the legal capacity to execute such document or instrument at the time of such execution.
(b) All documents submitted to us as originals are authentic, complete, and accurate, and all documents submitted to us as copies conform to the originals thereof, which originals are themselves authentic, complete, and accurate.
(c) The Mezzanine Lender is a limited partnership duly organized, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of its jurisdiction of formation, and has full limited partnership power and authority to enter into, execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which it is a party.
(d) Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of the Mezzanine Lender, enforceable against the Mezzanine Lender in accordance with its respective terms.
(e) All factual matters, statements, and representations set forth in the Officer's Certificates and in all other certificates, documents, and instruments reviewed by us in connection with this opinion letter are true, correct, and complete as of the date hereof, and no material facts have been withheld from us.
(f) Except as specifically opined upon herein with respect to the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, and MTDC, each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents has been duly authorized by all necessary action on the part of, and has been duly executed and delivered by, each party thereto (other than the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC).
(g) There has been no mutual mistake of fact or misunderstanding, fraud, duress, or undue influence with respect to any of the Mezzanine Loan Documents or the transactions contemplated thereby, and each Mezzanine Loan Document accurately reflects the complete agreement of the parties thereto with respect to the subject matter thereof.
(h) The conduct of all parties to the Mezzanine Loan Documents has complied and will comply with any requirement of good faith, fair dealing, and conscionability imposed by applicable law, and no party has engaged or will engage in any conduct that would render any provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents unenforceable.
(i) The Mezzanine Lender has acted and will act in good faith, without notice of any defense against the enforcement of any rights created by the Mezzanine Loan Documents, and in compliance with all applicable laws, rules, and regulations in connection with the making and administration of the Mezzanine Loan.
(j) No event has occurred and no condition exists that would make any of the factual representations or warranties made by any party in connection with the Mezzanine Loan Documents untrue or inaccurate in any material respect.
V. Opinions
Based upon the foregoing and subject to the assumptions set forth in Section IV above and the qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth in Section VI below, and having regard for such legal considerations as we deem relevant, we are of the opinion that:
Opinion 1 — Organization and Existence of Mezzanine Borrower (HYW Mezzanine)
Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC is a limited liability company duly formed, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of the State of Delaware. HYW Mezzanine is duly qualified to transact business and is in good standing as a foreign limited liability company in the State of New York. HYW Mezzanine has all requisite limited liability company power and authority to own, hold, and dispose of its assets, including, without limitation, one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC, to carry on its business as presently conducted, and to execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which it is a party.
Opinion 2 — Organization and Existence of HYW Mortgage (as Confirmation of Pledged Entity)
Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC is a limited liability company duly formed, validly existing, and in good standing under the laws of the State of Delaware. HYW Mortgage is duly qualified to transact business and is in good standing as a foreign limited liability company in the State of New York. The membership interests in HYW Mortgage that are pledged under the Pledge and Security Agreement (i.e., one hundred percent (100%) of the issued and outstanding membership interests in HYW Mortgage) have been duly authorized and validly issued in accordance with the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement and the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act (6 Del. C. § 18-101 et seq.). Such membership interests are fully paid and non-assessable to the extent that the concepts of "fully paid" and "non-assessable" are applicable to limited liability company interests under the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act. The Pledged Interests are owned of record by the Mezzanine Borrower, and, based solely on our review of the UCC Lien Search Results, the Officer's Certificates, and the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement, such interests are free and clear of all liens, security interests, encumbrances, pledges, charges, claims, and adverse claims of any kind whatsoever, other than the lien and security interest created in favor of the Mezzanine Lender by the Pledge and Security Agreement.
Opinion 3 — Authorization of MTDC as Guarantor
Metropolitan Transit Development Corp. is a government instrumentality duly created and validly existing under the laws of the State of Illinois, pursuant to the enabling legislation identified in Section III(h) above. MTDC has full power and authority under its enabling legislation and organizational documents to execute, deliver, and perform its obligations under the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement. The execution, delivery, and performance by MTDC of the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement have been duly authorized by all requisite action on the part of MTDC, including, without limitation, the adoption of a resolution by the Board of Directors of MTDC (Margaret Kowalski, Chair), at a duly called and held meeting of the Board at which a quorum was present, authorizing MTDC to enter into and perform its obligations under the Mezzanine Guaranty and the Environmental Indemnity Agreement and authorizing the officers of MTDC named therein to execute and deliver such documents on behalf of MTDC.
Opinion 4 — Due Authorization and Execution
Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower is a party has been duly authorized by all necessary limited liability company action on the part of the Mezzanine Borrower, in accordance with the HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement and the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act, and has been duly executed and delivered by the Mezzanine Borrower. Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which MTDC is a party has been duly authorized by all necessary corporate or governmental action on the part of MTDC, in accordance with the enabling legislation, bylaws, and applicable resolutions of the Board of Directors of MTDC, and has been duly executed and delivered by MTDC. No further action, approval, or consent on the part of the Mezzanine Borrower, its members or managers, or MTDC, its Board of Directors, officers, or any other person or body, is required to authorize the execution, delivery, and performance of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower and/or MTDC is a party.
Opinion 5 — Enforceability
Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which the Mezzanine Borrower is a party constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of the Mezzanine Borrower, enforceable against the Mezzanine Borrower in accordance with its respective terms. Each of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which MTDC is a party constitutes the legal, valid, and binding obligation of MTDC, enforceable against MTDC in accordance with its respective terms. The foregoing opinions regarding enforceability are subject, in each case, to the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) below.
Opinion 6 — Security Interest in Pledged Membership Interests
(a) The Pledge and Security Agreement is effective to create in favor of the Mezzanine Lender a valid security interest, within the meaning of Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code as in effect in the State of New York (the "NY UCC"), in the Pledged Interests (i.e., one hundred percent (100%) of the membership interests in Hudson Yards West Mortgage LLC held by the Mezzanine Borrower) and in all proceeds (as defined in Section 9-102(a)(64) of the NY UCC) thereof, as security for the obligations of the Mezzanine Borrower described in the Pledge and Security Agreement and the other Mezzanine Loan Documents.
(b) The Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles" within the meaning of Section 9-102(a)(42) of the NY UCC. We note that, if the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement were amended to "opt in" to Article 8 of the NY UCC, and if certificates representing the Pledged Interests were issued, the Pledged Interests (or portions thereof) might instead constitute "certificated securities" within the meaning of Section 8-102(a)(4) of the NY UCC. Based on our review of the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement and the Officer's Certificates delivered to us, the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement does not currently provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are securities governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, and no certificates have been issued to represent such interests.
(c) Upon the filing of UCC-1 financing statements naming the Mezzanine Borrower as debtor and the Mezzanine Lender as secured party, in proper form for filing, with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware (HYW Mezzanine being organized under the laws of the State of Delaware, and the State of Delaware being the jurisdiction in which filings are required to be made under Section 9-301(1) of the NY UCC to perfect a security interest in general intangibles of a debtor organized in that jurisdiction), the Mezzanine Lender's security interest in the Pledged Interests (to the extent the Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles" within the meaning of the NY UCC) will be perfected. If, at any time hereafter, the Pledged Interests are evidenced by certificates and the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement is amended to provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are securities governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, then perfection of the security interest in the Pledged Interests may also be accomplished or maintained by delivery of such certificates to the Mezzanine Lender (or its agent), endorsed in blank or accompanied by duly executed undated instruments of transfer in blank, in accordance with Article 8 of the NY UCC.
(d) Based solely on our review of the UCC Lien Search Results obtained from the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware on or about June 12, 2025, no prior UCC financing statement naming Hudson Yards West Mezzanine LLC as debtor and covering or purporting to cover the Pledged Interests has been filed in the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware. Accordingly, upon the filing of the UCC Financing Statements referenced herein in the office of the Delaware Secretary of State, the Mezzanine Lender's security interest in the Pledged Interests (to the extent the Pledged Interests constitute "general intangibles") will have first priority over any security interest that may be perfected by a financing statement filed subsequently in such office covering the same collateral, subject in all cases to the qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth in Section VI below.
Opinion 7 — No Conflicts
The execution, delivery, and performance by the Mezzanine Borrower and MTDC of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which each is a party, and the consummation of the transactions contemplated thereby, including, without limitation, the pledge and grant of a security interest in the Pledged Interests to the Mezzanine Lender, do not and will not:
(a) Violate or conflict with (i) the Certificate of Formation or the HYW Mezzanine LLC Agreement of the Mezzanine Borrower, (ii) the Certificate of Formation or the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement of HYW Mortgage, or (iii) the enabling legislation, bylaws, or other organizational documents of MTDC;
(b) Violate or conflict with any law, statute, rule, or regulation of the State of New York or the United States of America applicable to the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC that, in the experience of this Firm, is typically applicable to transactions of the type contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents. We note that we do not express any opinion on regulatory matters specific to government instrumentalities of the State of Illinois except to the extent expressly covered in Opinion 3 above based on our review of the enabling legislation and organizational documents of MTDC;
(c) Result in a breach of, or constitute a default (or an event that, with the giving of notice, the lapse of time, or both, would constitute a default) under, any agreement, indenture, mortgage, deed of trust, or other instrument listed on the Officer's Certificates delivered to this Firm, to which the Mezzanine Borrower, HYW Mortgage, or MTDC is a party or by which any of their respective properties or assets may be bound or affected; or
(d) Result in the creation or imposition of any lien, charge, pledge, security interest, encumbrance, or other restriction upon the Pledged Interests or any other property or assets of the Mezzanine Borrower, other than (i) the lien and security interest created by the Pledge and Security Agreement in favor of the Mezzanine Lender, and (ii) any filing of UCC financing statements as referenced herein and contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents.
Opinion 8 — No Consents or Approvals
No consent, approval, authorization, order, registration, qualification, designation, declaration, or filing with or by any governmental authority or agency of the State of New York or any agency or instrumentality of the United States of America is required for the valid execution, delivery, and performance by the Mezzanine Borrower or MTDC of the Mezzanine Loan Documents to which each is a party, or for the validity or enforceability of the Mezzanine Loan Documents, except: (i) such consents, approvals, authorizations, orders, registrations, qualifications, or filings as have been obtained or made on or prior to the date hereof and remain in full force and effect as of the date hereof; and (ii) the filing of UCC financing statements (and, in due course, continuation statements) with the office of the Secretary of State of the State of Delaware in connection with the perfection and maintenance of the security interest in the Pledged Interests granted pursuant to the Pledge and Security Agreement.
Opinion 9 — Choice of Law
Each Mezzanine Loan Document that by its terms is to be governed by the laws of the State of New York contains a valid and effective choice of the laws of the State of New York as the governing law of such Mezzanine Loan Document. Pursuant to Section 5-1401 of the New York General Obligations Law, which provides that a choice of New York law is effective where the parties have agreed that the law of the State of New York shall govern and the aggregate consideration payable under the contract exceeds $250,000, a court of the State of New York or a federal court sitting in the State of New York would give effect to such choice-of-law provisions, inasmuch as the principal amount of the Mezzanine Loan ($200,000,000) exceeds the statutory threshold set forth in N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Law § 5-1401. The foregoing opinion is subject to the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) below. We express no opinion as to the enforceability of any choice-of-law provision contained in any Mezzanine Loan Document that by its terms is to be governed by the law of a jurisdiction other than the State of New York, and we express no opinion as to whether a court of a jurisdiction other than New York would give effect to such choice-of-law provisions.
Opinion 10 — Usury
The charging, collection, and receipt of interest at the fixed rate of 11.50% per annum as provided in the Mezzanine Promissory Note and the Mezzanine Loan Agreement does not violate the usury laws of the State of New York. In rendering this opinion, we have taken into account that the original principal amount of the Mezzanine Loan is $200,000,000, which exceeds the threshold of $2,500,000 set forth in Section 5-501(6)(b) of the New York General Obligations Law, and accordingly, the maximum rate of interest provisions set forth in Section 5-501(1) and (2) of the New York General Obligations Law and Section 14-a(1) of the New York Banking Law are not applicable to the Mezzanine Loan. We note that this opinion is limited to the usury laws of the State of New York and does not address usury or interest rate limitations under the laws of any other jurisdiction. We further note that we express no opinion as to whether any fees, charges, or other amounts payable under the Mezzanine Loan Documents, when aggregated with interest, would cause the effective rate of return to the Mezzanine Lender to exceed any applicable usury limit, as we have assumed that all such fees and charges constitute bona fide fees for services or reimbursements and are not disguised interest.
VI. Qualifications, Limitations, and Exceptions
A. Enforceability Qualifications
The opinions expressed in this letter with respect to the enforceability of the Mezzanine Loan Documents are subject to the following qualifications (collectively, the "Enforceability Qualifications"):
(i) The effect of applicable bankruptcy, insolvency, reorganization, moratorium, receivership, conservatorship, fraudulent conveyance, fraudulent transfer, and other similar laws now or hereafter in effect affecting the enforcement of creditors' rights and remedies generally, including, without limitation, the effect of statutory and other laws regarding preferential transfers and fraudulent conveyances.
(ii) The effect of general principles of equity (regardless of whether enforcement is sought in a proceeding in equity or at law), including, without limitation, concepts of materiality, reasonableness, good faith, and fair dealing, and the possible unavailability of specific performance, injunctive relief, or other equitable remedies.
(iii) The effect of applicable public policy on the enforceability of provisions of the Mezzanine Loan Documents that purport to indemnify, hold harmless, or exculpate a party against or from liability for its own action or inaction, to the extent that such action or inaction involves negligence, gross negligence, bad faith, willful misconduct, or violation of applicable law.
(iv) The possible unenforceability, under certain circumstances, of provisions of the Mezzanine Loan Documents that impose penalties, forfeitures, increased interest rates (including default interest), or late charges upon delinquency in payment or the occurrence of a default, to the extent that such provisions are deemed to constitute unenforceable liquidated damages, penalties, or forfeitures under applicable law.
(v) Limitations imposed by applicable law on the enforceability of waivers, releases, and exculpation clauses, including, without limitation, waivers of rights to a trial by jury, waivers of service of process requirements, waivers of rights of redemption, waivers of appraisement or valuation rights, waivers of stay or extension laws, or waivers of any other statutory or constitutional rights that may not be waived as a matter of applicable law.
B. Other Qualifications, Limitations, and Exceptions
The opinions expressed in this letter are further subject to the following qualifications, limitations, and exceptions:
(i) The opinions expressed herein are limited to the laws of the State of New York, the Delaware Limited Liability Company Act (6 Del. C. § 18-101 et seq.), the Uniform Commercial Code as in effect in the State of New York and the State of Delaware, and the federal laws of the United States of America, in each case as in effect on the date hereof. We express no opinion as to the laws of any other jurisdiction, including, without limitation, the laws of the State of Illinois, except to the extent that MTDC's due authorization is confirmed in Opinion 3 above based on our review of its enabling legislation, organizational documents, and resolutions of its Board of Directors.
(ii) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to the financial or economic terms of the Mezzanine Loan, the adequacy or fairness of the consideration received by any party in connection with the Mezzanine Loan Documents, or the commercial reasonableness of any term or provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents.
(iii) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to Title 11 of the United States Code (the "Bankruptcy Code") or any state insolvency law or any similar law affecting the rights and remedies of creditors, except as specifically referenced in the Enforceability Qualifications set forth in Section VI(A) above.
(iv) No opinion is expressed herein with respect to federal or state securities laws (including the Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended), the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, as amended ("ERISA"), tax law (including federal, state, and local tax law), environmental law (including the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act), antitrust law, criminal law, intellectual property law, healthcare law, pension law, the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, anti-money laundering laws (including the USA PATRIOT Act), sanctions laws (including regulations administered by the Office of Foreign Assets Control), or the laws, rules, or regulations of any regulatory authority applicable specifically to government instrumentalities, public benefit corporations, or municipal entities.
(v) No opinion is expressed herein as to the effect of fraudulent conveyance, fraudulent transfer, or preference laws (whether arising under federal bankruptcy law or applicable state law) on the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents, including, without limitation, the enforceability of the Mezzanine Guaranty or the pledge of the Pledged Interests under the Pledge and Security Agreement.
(vi) No opinion is expressed herein regarding the enforceability of any provision of the Mezzanine Loan Documents requiring the payment of attorneys' fees, costs of collection, or expenses of enforcement, except to the extent permitted by applicable law and the discretion of the court before which enforcement is sought.
(vii) No opinion is expressed herein as to the priority of the security interest created by the Pledge and Security Agreement vis-à-vis (A) any purchase money security interest that may arise under applicable law, (B) any interest arising under federal law (including any tax lien arising under the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended), (C) any interest arising by operation of law (including, without limitation, any mechanics' lien, materialmen's lien, or statutory lien), or (D) any interest of a person who obtains control (as defined in Article 8 or Article 9 of the NY UCC, as applicable) of the Pledged Interests.
(viii) The opinions expressed herein regarding the Pledged Interests assume that the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement has not been amended to "opt in" to Article 8 of the NY UCC, and that no certificates representing the membership interests in HYW Mortgage have been issued, unless the Officer's Certificates expressly confirm otherwise. The characterization of the Pledged Interests as "general intangibles" within the meaning of the NY UCC is based upon that assumption. If the HYW Mortgage LLC Agreement is hereafter amended to provide that the membership interests in HYW Mortgage are "securities" governed by Article 8 of the NY UCC, or if certificates representing such interests are hereafter issued, the method of perfection applicable to the security interest in the Pledged Interests may change, and additional action may be required by the Mezzanine Lender to maintain perfection and priority of its security interest therein.
VII. Reliance and Benefit
This opinion letter is furnished solely for the benefit of Granite Peak Capital Partners, LP, in its capacity as Mezzanine Lender, and its successors and permitted assigns under the Mezzanine Loan Agreement (including any future holder of the Mezzanine Loan, any assignee or transferee of any interest in the Mezzanine Loan, and any participant in the Mezzanine Loan), in connection with the transactions contemplated by the Mezzanine Loan Documents. This opinion letter may not be relied upon by any other person or entity, or for any purpose other than in connection with the Mezzanine Loan, without the prior written consent of Calderwood & Harkness LLP.
This opinion letter is rendered as of the date hereof, and we express no opinion as to circumstances, events, or developments occurring after the date hereof. We undertake no obligation, and hereby disclaim any obligation, to advise you of any change in applicable law, or to update, revise, or supplement this opinion letter, to reflect any facts or circumstances that may hereafter come to our attention or any changes in law (whether by legislative action, judicial decision, or otherwise) that may hereafter occur, even if such changes would affect the opinions expressed herein.
Notwithstanding the foregoing, we hereby consent to the delivery of a copy of this opinion letter to (i) Voss Richter & Baines LLP, in its capacity as counsel to the Mezzanine Lender, and (ii) Pinnacle Ratings Group, in connection with any rating of the Mezzanine Loan or any securities backed, in whole or in part, by the Mezzanine Loan. Each such recipient may rely on this opinion letter as if it were an addressee hereof, subject to the same terms, conditions, assumptions, qualifications, limitations, and exceptions set forth herein.
Very truly yours,
CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP
By: ________
Name: Douglas Fairchild
Title: Partner
One Liberty Plaza, 55th Floor New York, New York 10006
C&H Matter No. 1031-00004

CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP Counselors at Law

CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP

Record

Parties

Dates

Amounts