FR EA
1034-00001 · Graystone & Falk LLP · Financial Analysis
fund-flow-analysis-tables.xlsx DOCUMENT Litigation
17 / 36 ← → ✕
Contract analysis Extract to table

[sheet: Summary]

Investment VehicleVehicle TypeEntity Type / JurisdictionDate of Initial InvestmentTotal Caldwell Equity InvestedTotal Distributions ReceivedBuyout / Redemption ProceedsNet Cash PositionNotes
Aegean Realty Fund III LPLimited Partnership (LP)Delaware LPJune 2016$2,500,000.00$620,000.00$0.00-$1,880,000.00Redeemed as part of Dec. 15, 2019 separation; redemption proceeds captured under Fund III–V combined. See Fund III tab.
Aegean Realty Fund IV LPLimited Partnership (LP)Delaware LPMarch 2017$4,000,000.00$750,000.00$0.00-$3,250,000.00Redeemed as part of Dec. 15, 2019 separation. See Fund IV tab.
Aegean Realty Fund V LPLimited Partnership (LP)Delaware LPSeptember 2018$3,500,000.00$500,000.00$3,150,000.00$150,000.00Redeemed March 2020 at $3,150,000 after 6-month notice period. See Fund V tab.
710 Flatbush Holdings LLCJoint Venture (50/50)New York LLCApril 2016$2,800,000.00$385,000.00$3,400,000.00$985,000.00Stavros buyout of Caldwell's 50% interest effective Dec. 15, 2019. See Flatbush JV tab.
Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLCJoint Venture (60/40 Stavros/Caldwell)New Jersey LLCOctober 2017$1,424,000.00$250,000.00$1,850,000.00$676,000.00Stavros buyout of Caldwell's 40% interest effective Dec. 15, 2019. See Newark JV tab.
TOTALS$14,224,000.00$2,505,000.00$8,400,000.00-$3,319,000.00Net cash outflow before accounting for Fund III and IV redemption proceeds embedded in separation agreement.

[sheet: Fund III]

Entry No.DateDescriptionSource AccountDestination AccountAmountDirectionRunning Balance — Caldwell Net CashBates Cross-Reference
12016-06-15Initial LP capital contribution to Aegean Realty Fund III LPCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account (Northern Capital Bank, N.A.)Aegean Realty Fund III LP capital account (Westlake Fidelity Bank, N.A.)$2,500,000.00Outflow-$2,500,000.00CALDWELL-00247; CALDWELL-00248
22017-03-31Q1 2017 distribution — Fund IIIAegean Realty Fund III LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$155,000.00Inflow-$2,345,000.00CALDWELL-00412
32017-09-30Q3 2017 distribution — Fund IIIAegean Realty Fund III LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$140,000.00Inflow-$2,205,000.00CALDWELL-00589
42018-03-31Q1 2018 distribution — Fund IIIAegean Realty Fund III LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$125,000.00Inflow-$2,080,000.00CALDWELL-00734
52018-09-30Q3 2018 distribution — Fund IIIAegean Realty Fund III LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$110,000.00Inflow-$1,970,000.00CALDWELL-00891
62019-03-31Q1 2019 distribution — Fund IIIAegean Realty Fund III LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$90,000.00Inflow-$1,880,000.00CALDWELL-01023
72019-12-15Redemption of LP interest per separation agreement (Whitmore & Kessler LLP negotiated) — amount embedded in overall separation; not separately broken out in available recordsAegean Realty Fund III LP / StavrosCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating accountSee NotesInflowSee NotesCALDWELL-01456; CALDWELL-01457
TOTAL DISTRIBUTIONS (Entries 2–6)$620,000.00-$1,880,000.00

[sheet: Fund IV]

Entry No.DateDescriptionSource AccountDestination AccountAmountDirectionRunning Balance — Caldwell Net CashBates Cross-Reference
12017-03-10Initial LP capital contribution to Aegean Realty Fund IV LPCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account (Northern Capital Bank, N.A.)Aegean Realty Fund IV LP capital account (Harborview Trust Company escrow)$4,000,000.00Outflow-$4,000,000.00CALDWELL-00378; CALDWELL-00379
22017-12-31Q4 2017 distribution — Fund IVAegean Realty Fund IV LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$180,000.00Inflow-$3,820,000.00CALDWELL-00521
32018-06-30Q2 2018 distribution — Fund IVAegean Realty Fund IV LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$165,000.00Inflow-$3,655,000.00CALDWELL-00766
42018-12-31Q4 2018 distribution — Fund IVAegean Realty Fund IV LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$150,000.00Inflow-$3,505,000.00CALDWELL-00923
52019-06-30Q2 2019 distribution — Fund IVAegean Realty Fund IV LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$140,000.00Inflow-$3,365,000.00CALDWELL-01089
62019-09-30Q3 2019 distribution — Fund IVAegean Realty Fund IV LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$115,000.00Inflow-$3,250,000.00CALDWELL-01201
72019-12-15Redemption of LP interest per separation agreement (Whitmore & Kessler LLP negotiated) — amount embedded in overall separation; not separately broken out in available records. SENSITIVITY: Government alleges ~$18.7M diverted from Funds IV and V.Aegean Realty Fund IV LP / StavrosCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating accountSee NotesInflowSee NotesCALDWELL-01456; CALDWELL-01458
TOTAL DISTRIBUTIONS (Entries 2–6)$750,000.00-$3,250,000.00

[sheet: Fund V]

Entry No.DateDescriptionSource AccountDestination AccountAmountDirectionRunning Balance — Caldwell Net CashBates Cross-Reference
12018-09-20Initial LP capital contribution to Aegean Realty Fund V LPCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account (Northern Capital Bank, N.A.)Aegean Realty Fund V LP capital account (Harborview Trust Company escrow)$3,500,000.00Outflow-$3,500,000.00CALDWELL-00856; CALDWELL-00857
22019-03-31Q1 2019 distribution — Fund VAegean Realty Fund V LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$175,000.00Inflow-$3,325,000.00CALDWELL-01034
32019-09-30Q3 2019 distribution — Fund VAegean Realty Fund V LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$165,000.00Inflow-$3,160,000.00CALDWELL-01198
42019-12-31Q4 2019 distribution — Fund VAegean Realty Fund V LP distribution accountCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$160,000.00Inflow-$3,000,000.00CALDWELL-01345
52019-10-15Redemption notice submitted (6-month notice period per LPA)N/AN/A$0.00N/A-$3,000,000.00CALDWELL-01267
62020-03-15Redemption of Fund V LP interest — proceeds receivedAegean Realty Fund V LPCaldwell Capital Advisors LLC operating account$3,150,000.00Inflow$150,000.00CALDWELL-01678; CALDWELL-01679
TOTAL DISTRIBUTIONS (Entries 2–4)$500,000.00
TOTAL REDEMPTION PROCEEDS (Entry 6)$3,150,000.00
NET CASH POSITION (Fund V)$150,000.00SENSITIVITY: Government alleges ~$18.7M diverted from Funds IV and V; distributions and redemption proceeds may have been sourced from diverted capital.

[sheet: Flatbush JV]

Entry No.DateDescriptionSource AccountDestination AccountAmountDirectionRunning Balance — Caldwell Net CashBates Cross-Reference
12016-04-08Equity contribution — Caldwell 50% share of acquisition equity for 710 Flatbush Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11225 (42-unit mixed-use building; total acquisition price $11,200,000; total equity $5,600,000; Westlake Fidelity Bank loan $5,600,000)Jonathan R. Caldwell personal account / JRC Realty Holdings LLC710 Flatbush Holdings LLC closing escrow$2,800,000.00Outflow-$2,800,000.00CALDWELL-00189; CALDWELL-00190; CALDWELL-00191
22016-12-31Q4 2016 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$45,000.00Inflow-$2,755,000.00CALDWELL-00334
32017-06-30Q2 2017 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$52,000.00Inflow-$2,703,000.00CALDWELL-00467
42017-12-31Q4 2017 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$48,000.00Inflow-$2,655,000.00CALDWELL-00556
52018-06-30Q2 2018 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$55,000.00Inflow-$2,600,000.00CALDWELL-00788
62018-12-31Q4 2018 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$50,000.00Inflow-$2,550,000.00CALDWELL-00934
72019-06-30Q2 2019 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$60,000.00Inflow-$2,490,000.00CALDWELL-01102
82019-09-30Q3 2019 operating distribution — Flatbush JV (50% share)710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$75,000.00Inflow-$2,415,000.00CALDWELL-01189
92019-10-01Dispute arises: Stavros unilaterally charged ~$340,000 in management fees to 710 Flatbush Holdings LLC operating account — precipitated October 2019 falling-out and December 2019 separationN/A — notation onlyN/A — notation only$0.00N/A-$2,415,000.00CALDWELL-01234; CALDWELL-01235
102019-12-15Buyout — Stavros purchases Caldwell's 50% interest in 710 Flatbush Holdings LLC per separation agreement (Whitmore & Kessler LLP / Patricia Sheldon)Marcus W. Stavros / Aegean Realty Partners LLCJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$3,400,000.00Inflow$985,000.00CALDWELL-01456; CALDWELL-01459; CALDWELL-01460
TOTAL DISTRIBUTIONS (Entries 2–8)$385,000.00
TOTAL BUYOUT PROCEEDS (Entry 10)$3,400,000.00
NET CASH POSITION (Flatbush JV)$985,000.00No direct transfers between Caldwell accounts and Stavros personal accounts identified.

[sheet: Newark JV]

Entry No.DateDescriptionSource AccountDestination AccountAmountDirectionRunning Balance — Caldwell Net CashBates Cross-Reference
12017-10-12Equity contribution — Caldwell 40% share of acquisition equity for 1500 Commerce Boulevard, Newark, NJ 07114 (65,000 sq. ft. industrial warehouse; total acquisition price $8,900,000; total equity $3,560,000; Westlake Fidelity Bank loan $5,340,000)Jonathan R. Caldwell personal account / JRC Realty Holdings LLCStavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC closing escrow$1,424,000.00Outflow-$1,424,000.00CALDWELL-00512; CALDWELL-00513
22018-03-31Q1 2018 operating distribution — Newark JV (40% share)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$35,000.00Inflow-$1,389,000.00CALDWELL-00698
32018-09-30Q3 2018 operating distribution — Newark JV (40% share)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$40,000.00Inflow-$1,349,000.00CALDWELL-00878
42019-03-31Q1 2019 operating distribution — Newark JV (40% share)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$45,000.00Inflow-$1,304,000.00CALDWELL-01056
52019-06-30Q2 2019 operating distribution — Newark JV (40% share)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$42,000.00Inflow-$1,262,000.00CALDWELL-01134
62019-09-30Q3 2019 operating distribution — Newark JV (40% share)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$48,000.00Inflow-$1,214,000.00CALDWELL-01205
72019-12-01Q4 2019 partial distribution — Newark JV (40% share, pre-separation)Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC operating accountJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$40,000.00Inflow-$1,174,000.00CALDWELL-01389
82019-12-15Buyout — Stavros purchases Caldwell's 40% interest in Stavros-Caldwell Industrial LLC per separation agreement (Whitmore & Kessler LLP / Patricia Sheldon)Marcus W. Stavros / Aegean Realty Partners LLCJonathan R. Caldwell personal account$1,850,000.00Inflow$676,000.00CALDWELL-01456; CALDWELL-01461; CALDWELL-01462
TOTAL DISTRIBUTIONS (Entries 2–7)$250,000.00
TOTAL BUYOUT PROCEEDS (Entry 8)$1,850,000.00
NET CASH POSITION (Newark JV)$676,000.00No direct transfers between Caldwell accounts and Stavros personal accounts identified.