1036-00004
· Client 1036 · Engagement & Matter Management
budget-fee-estimate-memorandum.xlsx
DOCUMENT
Real Estate
[sheet: Cover & Summary]
Field
MEMORANDUM
| TO: | Angela Fontaine, Billing Partner — Calderwood & Harkness LLP |
| FROM: | Douglas Fairchild, Responsible Partner — Calderwood & Harkness LLP |
| DATE: | October 15, 2023 |
| RE: | Budget & Fee Estimate — Fairwater REIT Acquisition of GMP Fund III 14-Property Sun Belt Portfolio |
| MATTER NUMBER: | 1036-00004 |
| CLIENT: | Fairwater Real Estate Investment Trust |
| CLIENT CONTACT: | David Elgin Park, General Counsel; Camille Oduya, In-House Real Estate Counsel |
| TRANSACTION: | $1,100,000,000 entity-level acquisition of 14 property-owning Delaware LLCs from Greystone Meridian Partners Fund III, L.P. |
| ENGAGEMENT LETTER DATE: | October 5, 2023 |
| FEE CAP: | $2,800,000 (plus disbursements per engagement letter) |
| ESTIMATED DISBURSEMENTS: | $85,000 – $110,000 (travel, filing fees, courier, copying, database searches) |
| PROJECTED TOTAL FEES: | $2,720,000 (targeting ~$80,000 cushion below cap) |
| PROJECTED TOTAL HOURS: | ~4,850 hours |
| BLENDED EFFECTIVE RATE: | ~$561/hour ($2,720,000 ÷ 4,850) |
| ENGAGEMENT TEAM: | Douglas Fairchild (Responsible Partner); Angela Fontaine (Billing Partner); Grace Nakamura (Lead Associate); Rafael Dominguez (Working Associate); Sylvia Hartwell (Specialist Partner, Tax) |
| LOCAL COUNSEL (5 JURISDICTIONS): | Breckenridge Osgood LLP (TX); Talmadge Beaumont LLP (GA); Haversham Cole PLLC (NC); Ellsworth Ridley LLP (TN); Palmetto Strauss PA (FL) |
| NOTE: | Local counsel fees are separate from the C&H fee cap and will be billed directly to client or passed through as disbursements. Estimated aggregate local counsel fees: $280,000 – $340,000. |
| SCOPE OVERVIEW: | Transaction/PSA drafting & negotiation; due diligence (title, survey, lease, environmental, PCA, entity-level, zoning, insurance, service contracts); lender consent workstream (3 lenders, $612M assumed debt); title & survey clearance (14 properties, 5 states); tax advisory (REIT qualification, transfer tax, FIRPTA, Section 1060 allocation); closing & post-closing deliverables |
| ASSUMPTIONS: | Entity-level purchase of 100% membership interests in 14 SPEs; 87 leases requiring estoppel review; 3 mortgage lenders requiring change of control consent; 5-state title/survey/local law coverage; 90-day post-closing transition period |
| PREPARED BY: | Douglas Fairchild, Responsible Partner |
| DISTRIBUTION: | Angela Fontaine (Billing Partner); Finance Department — Calderwood & Harkness LLP |
[sheet: Workstream Budget]
| Workstream | Sub-Task | Fairchild — Partner Hrs | Fairchild — Rate | Fontaine — Partner Hrs | Fontaine — Rate | Hartwell — Partner Hrs | Hartwell — Rate | Nakamura — Sr. Assoc. Hrs | Nakamura — Rate | Dominguez — Assoc. Hrs | Dominguez — Rate | Total Hours | Total Fees | % of Fee Cap |
| I. ENGAGEMENT & MATTER MANAGEMENT | Engagement letter, conflicts, staffing, budget | 15 | $1,150 | 8 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 10 | $725 | 5 | $575 | 38 | $34,450 | 1.2% |
| II. LOI & PRE-PSA | LOI review/drafting, NDA, exclusivity extension, structure memo, DD request list, data room protocol | 30 | $1,150 | 5 | $1,100 | 25 | $1,150 | 60 | $725 | 40 | $575 | 160 | $120,275 | 4.3% |
| III. PSA DRAFTING & NEGOTIATION | Initial draft PSA (87 pages + 22 exhibits, 14+ schedules), markup cycles, amendments, blackline | 120 | $1,150 | 10 | $1,100 | 30 | $1,150 | 280 | $725 | 200 | $575 | 640 | $502,750 | 18.0% |
| III. PSA DRAFTING & NEGOTIATION | Exhibit preparation (Exhibits A–V), including rent roll review, allocation schedule, proration methodology, escrow agreement, form estoppel, form SNDA, form guaranty, transition services agreement | 40 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 15 | $1,150 | 120 | $725 | 100 | $575 | 275 | $207,250 | 7.4% |
| III. PSA DRAFTING & NEGOTIATION | Disclosure schedules review (Schedules 1, 2-1 through 2-14) | 10 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 5 | $1,150 | 50 | $725 | 40 | $575 | 105 | $71,750 | 2.6% |
| Subtotal — PSA Drafting & Negotiation | 170 | 10 | 50 | 450 | 340 | 1020 | $781,750 | 27.9% | ||||||
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Title review — 14 properties across GA, TX, FL, TN, NC (commitments, exception documents, objections, cures) | 25 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 80 | $725 | 100 | $575 | 205 | $143,375 | 5.1% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Survey review — 14 ALTA/NSPS surveys, instruction letter, comment letter, certifications | 10 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 40 | $725 | 60 | $575 | 110 | $74,900 | 2.7% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Lease audit — 87 leases portfolio summary + top 10 tenant detailed memo | 20 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 100 | $725 | 120 | $575 | 240 | $164,500 | 5.9% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Environmental DD — review 14 Phase I ESAs (including Westlake and Lakeland de minimis RECs), memo | 5 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 25 | $725 | 30 | $575 | 60 | $41,225 | 1.5% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | PCA review — 14 PCAs, $2,140,000 immediate repairs, negotiate credit ($1,070,000), memo | 5 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 20 | $725 | 25 | $575 | 50 | $34,575 | 1.2% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Zoning/land use — 14 properties, coordinate with local counsel, confirmation letters | 5 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 15 | $725 | 25 | $575 | 45 | $31,225 | 1.1% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Entity-level DD — org docs, good standing, UCC searches, litigation searches (14 Target Entities + Seller) | 5 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 20 | $725 | 35 | $575 | 60 | $40,850 | 1.5% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Loan document review — Pinnacle ($421.6M, 8 loans), Veltrano ($142.3M, 4 loans), Sycamore ($48.1M, 2 loans) | 20 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 60 | $725 | 70 | $575 | 150 | $106,750 | 3.8% |
| IV. DUE DILIGENCE | Insurance coverage review, service contract review (63 contracts), comprehensive DD summary memo | 10 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 30 | $725 | 40 | $575 | 80 | $56,100 | 2.0% |
| Subtotal — Due Diligence | 105 | 0 | 0 | 390 | 505 | 1000 | $693,500 | 24.8% | ||||||
| V. LENDER CONSENT WORKSTREAM | Strategy memo, consent request letters (3 lenders), replacement guaranty drafting/negotiation, assumption agreements, consent fee coordination ($1,825,625 total) | 40 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 100 | $725 | 80 | $575 | 220 | $164,500 | 5.9% |
| VI. TITLE & SURVEY DELIVERABLES | Commitment summary chart, pro forma policies, endorsement requests, premium allocation ($2,420,000), marked-up commitments, gap indemnity, title affidavits | 15 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 50 | $725 | 60 | $575 | 125 | $88,125 | 3.1% |
| VII. ESTOPPELS & SNDAs | Estoppel tracking (87 tenants, 91.4% ABR target), transmittal, review (6 discrepancies), compilation; SNDA tracking (38 Major Tenants), transmittal, compilation (34 at closing + 4 post-closing), compliance certificate | 15 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 60 | $725 | 70 | $575 | 145 | $101,425 | 3.6% |
| VIII. TAX WORKSTREAM | Structure memo, transfer tax analysis (5 states, $3,850,000 est.), FIRPTA analysis, PP allocation (Section 1060), REIT qualification impact, state income/franchise tax, transfer tax returns, Form 8594 draft | 15 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 120 | $1,150 | 30 | $725 | 20 | $575 | 185 | $181,650 | 6.5% |
| IX. CLOSING | Pre-closing checklist, closing agenda, 14 assignment & assumption agreements, closing certificates, FIRPTA certificate, secretary's certificates, escrow agreements ($16.5M indemnity + $55M deposit), proration statement, settlement statements, bill of sale, assignment of leases/contracts, transition services agreement, tenant notification letters, funds flow memo, wire instructions/confirmations | 50 | $1,150 | 5 | $1,100 | 10 | $1,150 | 120 | $725 | 150 | $575 | 335 | $241,750 | 8.6% |
| X. POST-CLOSING | Obligations tracker, 14 A&R operating agreements, DE manager change filings, foreign qualification filings (5 states), UCC-3 filings, property management transition memo, tenant notification confirmation, proration true-up analysis ($347,218 net credit to Buyer), SNDA post-closing delivery confirmation, indemnity escrow release instructions, title policy issuance confirmation | 25 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 10 | $1,150 | 60 | $725 | 80 | $575 | 175 | $128,100 | 4.6% |
| XI. R&W INSURANCE | Broker submission memo, policy review ($55M limit, $11M retention, $1,402,500 premium), no-claims declaration, premium wire confirmation — coordination with Hartwick Gunderson / Sentinel Specialty | 10 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 25 | $725 | 20 | $575 | 55 | $40,925 | 1.5% |
| XII. LOCAL COUNSEL COORDINATION | Engagement scoping, opinion requirements, recording confirmations — Breckenridge Osgood (TX), Talmadge Beaumont (GA), Haversham Cole (NC), Ellsworth Ridley (TN), Palmetto Strauss (FL) | 10 | $1,150 | 0 | $1,100 | 0 | $1,150 | 20 | $725 | 30 | $575 | 60 | $43,350 | 1.5% |
| XIII. INTERNAL CORRESPONDENCE & CLIENT COMMUNICATION | Key client emails, counterparty correspondence, deal team calls, weekly status updates | 30 | $1,150 | 5 | $1,100 | 5 | $1,150 | 40 | $725 | 30 | $575 | 110 | $83,950 | 3.0% |
| GRAND TOTAL | 530 | 33 | 220 | 1420 | 1430 | 3633 | $2,720,000 | 97.1% | ||||||
| REMAINING CUSHION BELOW $2,800,000 CAP | $80,000 | 2.9% |
[sheet: Timekeeper Summary]
| Timekeeper | Role | Office | Standard Rate ($/hr) | Projected Hours | Projected Fees | % of Total Fees |
| Douglas Fairchild | Responsible Partner, Real Estate | New York | $1,150 | 530 | $609,500 | 22.4% |
| Angela Fontaine | Billing Partner, Real Estate | New York | $1,100 | 33 | $36,300 | 1.3% |
| Sylvia Hartwell | Specialist Partner, Tax | Washington, DC | $1,150 | 220 | $253,000 | 9.3% |
| Grace Nakamura | Lead Associate, Real Estate | New York | $725 | 1420 | $1,029,500 | 37.8% |
| Rafael Dominguez | Working Associate, Real Estate | Washington, DC | $575 | 1430 | $822,250 | 30.2% |
| TOTAL | 3633 | $2,720,000 | 100.0% | |||
| FEE CAP | $2,800,000 | |||||
| CUSHION | $80,000 | 2.9% |
[sheet: Phased Timeline]
| Phase | Period | Key Milestone(s) | Primary Workstreams Active | Estimated Hours | Estimated Fees | Cumulative Fees | % of Fee Cap Consumed |
| Phase 1: Engagement & Pre-PSA | Oct 2, 2023 – Feb 27, 2024 | Matter opened (10/2/23); Engagement letter (10/5/23); NDA (10/10/23); LOI executed (10/18/23); Exclusivity commenced (11/15/23); Exclusivity extended to 1/31/24 (12/15/23); Initial draft PSA circulated (1/8/24); PSA negotiation rounds | Engagement & Matter Mgmt; LOI & Pre-PSA; PSA Drafting (initial); Structure Memo; Tax Structure Memo; DD Request List; R&W Broker Submission | 850 | $595,000 | $595,000 | 21.3% |
| Phase 2: PSA Signing & Due Diligence | Feb 28, 2024 – Apr 15, 2024 | PSA executed (2/28/24); Earnest Money Deposit $27.5M due (3/1/24); Survey review comments (3/15/24); Title objection letter (3/27/24 — deadline 3/29/24); Lender consent requests sent (3/8/24); Title cure response (4/8/24–4/11/24); Comprehensive DD summary (4/10/24); DD Period expires (4/15/24) | PSA Exhibits/Schedules finalization; All DD workstreams (title, survey, lease, env, PCA, zoning, entity, loans, insurance, service contracts); Lender Consent initiation; Title & Survey; Estoppel transmittal (3/4/24) | 1200 | $840,000 | $1,435,000 | 51.3% |
| Phase 3: Post-DD / Pre-Closing | Apr 16, 2024 – Jun 5, 2024 | Additional Deposit $27.5M hard (4/16/24); PSA First Amendment — estoppel deadline extension & PCA credit (4/12/24); Estoppel review — 6 discrepancies flagged (5/8/24); Estoppel/SNDA delivery deadline (5/15/24); Lender consent deadline (5/24/24); Veltrano consent received (5/17/24); Sycamore consent received (5/22/24); PSA Second Amendment — closing extension to 6/7/24 (5/28/24); Pinnacle consent received (6/4/24) | Lender Consent negotiation & guaranty finalization; Estoppel/SNDA tracking & review; Title deliverables finalization; Tax filings preparation; R&W policy finalization; Closing document preparation; Local counsel coordination | 1050 | $735,000 | $2,170,000 | 77.5% |
| Phase 4: Closing | Jun 6, 2024 | Actual closing date; 14 assignment & assumption agreements; closing certificates; funds flow ($486.93M net cash to Seller); escrow releases ($55M deposits); indemnity escrow funding ($16.5M); consent fees wired ($1,825,625); transfer taxes ($3,850,000); title premiums ($2,420,000); R&W premium ($1,402,500); SNDA holdback ($200,000) | Closing execution; Settlement statements; Wire confirmations; Tenant notifications | 280 | $200,000 | $2,370,000 | 84.6% |
| Phase 5: Post-Closing | Jun 7, 2024 – Sep 4, 2024 | Tenant notifications mailed (6/7/24); 4 remaining SNDAs received (7/2/24); $200K holdback released; Title policies issued (7/15/24); A&R operating agreements; DE filings; Foreign qualification updates (5 states); UCC-3 filings; Proration true-up analysis ($347,218 net credit to Buyer); True-up statement agreed (8/28/24); Payment by Seller (9/5/24) | Post-closing filings; Property management transition; Proration true-up; Escrow administration | 253 | $180,000 | $2,550,000 | 91.1% |
| Contingency / Unallocated Reserve | Throughout | Unanticipated issues, additional negotiation rounds, supplemental client reporting | All | 200 | $170,000 | $2,720,000 | 97.1% |
| TOTAL | 3833 | $2,720,000 | $2,720,000 | 97.1% |
[sheet: Disbursements Estimate]
| Category | Description | Estimated Amount |
| Travel | Partner and associate travel to Atlanta (closing, site visits), Houston, Miami — airfare, hotel, ground transport | $35,000 |
| Filing Fees | Delaware Secretary of State filings (14 certificates of amendment), foreign qualification filings (5 states), UCC-3 filings | $12,000 |
| Database / Search Fees | UCC, judgment, lien, litigation, and bankruptcy searches for 14 Target Entities and Seller across DE and 5 property states | $8,500 |
| Courier & Overnight Delivery | Document delivery to lenders, title company, local counsel, closing packages | $4,500 |
| Copying & Printing | Closing binders, document compilations, executed originals | $6,000 |
| Online Research / Westmark Data Systems | Legal research allocable to matter | $7,500 |
| Meals & Incidentals | Working meals during closing, extended negotiation sessions | $3,000 |
| Conference Calls / Video | Multi-party conference bridges for lender consent calls, closing calls | $1,500 |
| Miscellaneous | Notarization, recording verification, miscellaneous | $2,000 |
| TOTAL ESTIMATED DISBURSEMENTS | $80,000 | |
| HIGH-END ESTIMATE | $110,000 |
[sheet: Local Counsel Estimates]
| Jurisdiction | Local Counsel Firm | Lead Partner | Properties Covered | # of Target Entities | Scope | Estimated Fee Range | Low Estimate | High Estimate |
| Texas | Breckenridge Osgood LLP | James Breckenridge | Westlake Distribution Hub; Katy Freeway Logistics Park; Alliance Commerce Center | 3 | Title endorsements, transfer tax compliance (no state transfer tax — nominal local fees), local law opinion, recording confirmations | $45,000 – $60,000 | $45,000 | $60,000 |
| Georgia | Talmadge Beaumont LLP | Catherine Beaumont | Fairfield Logistics Center I & II; Buckhead Place Office Tower; Peachtree Corners Logistics Center | 4 | Title endorsements, controlling-interest transfer tax declarations (~$1,250,000 transfer tax), local law opinion, recording confirmations | $65,000 – $80,000 | $65,000 | $80,000 |
| North Carolina | Haversham Cole PLLC | Marshall Haversham | SouthPark Corporate Center | 1 | Title endorsements, transfer tax compliance (~$180,000 transfer tax), local law opinion, recording confirmations | $25,000 – $35,000 | $25,000 | $35,000 |
| Tennessee | Ellsworth Ridley LLP | Diane Ellsworth | Murfreesboro Distribution Center; Cool Springs Office Park; Mount Juliet Commerce Park | 3 | Title endorsements, transfer tax compliance (~$740,000 transfer tax), local law opinion, recording confirmations | $50,000 – $65,000 | $50,000 | $65,000 |
| Florida | Palmetto Strauss PA | Roberto Strauss | Lakeland Crossings Industrial; Southport Logistics Park; Brickell Bay Office Building | 3 | Title endorsements, documentary stamp tax compliance (~$1,680,000 transfer tax), local law opinion, recording confirmations | $55,000 – $70,000 | $55,000 | $70,000 |
| TOTAL | 14 | $240,000 – $310,000 | $240,000 | $310,000 |