FR EA
1039-00005 · Torchlight Mining Corp · Government Engagement
privilege-log.xlsx DOCUMENT Litigation
19 / 35 ← → ✕
Contract analysis Extract to table

[sheet: Privilege Log]

Log Entry No.Bates Range WithheldDocument DateDocument TypeAuthor(s)Recipient(s) / Addressee(s)CC / Other RecipientsGeneral DescriptionPrivilege BasisPrivilege Sub-BasisPages WithheldAttachments WithheldNotes
1TRCH-PRIV-000001 – TRCH-PRIV-0000122025-03-05LetterConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPPatricia Sung, General Counsel, Torchlight Mining Corp.Victoria Chambers, Calderwood & Harkness LLPEngagement letter formalizing the retention of Calderwood & Harkness LLP to conduct an internal investigation into potential FCPA violations related to Torchlight Mining Corp.'s West African operationsAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication establishing attorney-client relationship and providing legal advice regarding scope and conduct of internal investigation12No
2TRCH-PRIV-000013 – TRCH-PRIV-0000212025-03-07MemorandumConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPVictoria Chambers, Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPInternal memorandum outlining the scope and work plan for the internal investigation, including identification of key subjects, document collection priorities, and witness interview schedule related to potential FCPA violationsBothWork product prepared in anticipation of litigation reflecting attorney mental impressions, legal analysis, and case strategy9Yes (1 — draft timeline attachment)
3TRCH-PRIV-000022 – TRCH-PRIV-0000252025-03-08LetterConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLP (on behalf of Torchlight Mining Corp.)Robert Dalton Jr., Claims Counsel, Dalton & Mercer Inc.Patricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Notice of claim letter to D&O insurer under Policy No. DM-0092-FCPA-2024 describing SEC and DOJ investigations and requesting confirmation of coverageAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication prepared by counsel conveying legal advice and strategy regarding insurance coverage in connection with government investigations4No
4TRCH-PRIV-000026 – TRCH-PRIV-0000322025-03-10AgreementConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLP; Richard Bartlett III, Bartlett Keene & Ostrander LLPPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Common interest agreement between Calderwood & Harkness LLP and Bartlett Keene & Ostrander LLP governing the sharing of privileged materials related to the investigation of potential FCPA and CFPOA violationsAttorney-Client PrivilegeAgreement to maintain privilege over shared communications between co-counsel providing coordinated legal advice7No
5TRCH-PRIV-000033 – TRCH-PRIV-0000362025-03-11MemorandumSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPInternal memorandum analyzing the SEC formal document subpoena served February 3, 2025 (File No. HO-14892), identifying responsive document categories, privilege issues, and proposed rolling production scheduleBothAttorney work product containing legal analysis and litigation strategy regarding response to government subpoena4No
6TRCH-PRIV-000037 – TRCH-PRIV-0000422025-03-12LetterSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPDr. Leonard Strauss, Pinnacle Forensic Advisory LLCConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPRetention letter engaging Pinnacle Forensic Advisory LLC to conduct forensic accounting review of TGH and TGM financial records at the direction and under the supervision of counselBothCommunication with expert retained at direction of counsel in anticipation of litigation; work product protection extends to scope and direction of expert work6No
7TRCH-PRIV-000043 – TRCH-PRIV-0000462025-03-14LetterSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPRachel Hartley, Marlowe Asset Management Digital Forensics Inc.Conrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPRetention letter engaging Marlowe Asset Management Digital Forensics Inc. for forensic data collection, processing, and hosting of approximately 1.625 TB of data across 23 custodians at the direction of counselBothCommunication with vendor retained at direction of counsel in anticipation of litigation4No
8TRCH-PRIV-000047 – TRCH-PRIV-0000502025-03-14EmailSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPDr. Leonard Strauss, Pinnacle Forensic Advisory LLCJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPEmail directing initial forensic accounting work plan, prioritizing review of Crestfield Advisory Partners Ltd. invoice register, wire transfer records from Meridian Commercial Bank, and TGM general ledger entriesBothAttorney work product directing expert investigation at counsel's direction; reflects attorney mental impressions regarding investigative priorities4Yes (1 — draft priority item list)
9TRCH-PRIV-000051 – TRCH-PRIV-0000552025-03-17Memorandum / NoticeCalderwood & Harkness LLP23 identified custodians (12 current employees, 4 former employees, 7 shared/departmental mailboxes), Torchlight Mining Corp., TGH, and TGMPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Litigation hold notice prepared by counsel directing preservation of all documents from January 1, 2018 to present related to Ganaran operations, Crestfield Advisory Partners Ltd., and named government officialsAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication from counsel providing legal advice regarding document preservation obligations5Yes (1 — custodian acknowledgment form)
10TRCH-PRIV-000056 – TRCH-PRIV-0000582025-03-18LetterConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMargaret Calloway, Assistant Chief, FCPA Unit, DOJ Criminal Division, Fraud SectionPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Letter acknowledging receipt of DOJ voluntary document preservation request dated February 14, 2025, confirming litigation hold, and expressing willingness to cooperateAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication by counsel on behalf of client with government agency reflecting legal strategy and advice3NoPartially privileged; redacted version produced as TRCH-SEC-004215 – TRCH-SEC-004217
11TRCH-PRIV-000059 – TRCH-PRIV-0000682025-03-19MemorandumJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum analyzing the Government Relations Advisory Agreement dated April 12, 2019 between TGH and Crestfield Advisory Partners Ltd., identifying contractual terms, red flags, and compliance deficienciesBothAttorney work product containing legal analysis of contractual provisions and assessment of potential FCPA exposure10Yes (1 — copy of Crestfield Advisory Agreement with attorney annotations)Underlying unannotated agreement produced as TRCH-SEC-001044 – TRCH-SEC-001058
12TRCH-PRIV-000069 – TRCH-PRIV-0000742025-03-24MemorandumConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.; Dr. Eleanor Fiske, Audit Committee Chair; Warren Ogilvy, Audit Committee Member; Marguerite Chen, Audit Committee MemberMemorandum analyzing strategic considerations for voluntary self-disclosure to the DOJ under the Corporate Enforcement Policy, including potential credit, cooperation obligations, and comparison of potential outcomesBothAttorney-client communication providing legal advice regarding litigation strategy and government enforcement exposure; work product reflecting attorney mental impressions6No
13TRCH-PRIV-000075 – TRCH-PRIV-0000782025-03-25EmailConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPHelen Whitmore, Whitmore & Sharpe LLPSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPEmail requesting voluntary interview with former VP, Africa Operations Marcus Delacroix in connection with internal investigation, proposing videoconference formatBothAttorney work product reflecting investigative strategy; communication between counsel4No
14TRCH-PRIV-000079 – TRCH-PRIV-0000822025-03-26EmailSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPBarrister Emeka Okoro, Okoro Law ChambersJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPEmail requesting voluntary interview with former Country Manager Raymond Osei-Bonsu in connection with internal investigation, proposing videoconference formatBothAttorney work product reflecting investigative strategy; communication between counsel4No
15TRCH-PRIV-000083 – TRCH-PRIV-0000902025-03-28MemorandumSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum enumerating red flags identified in preliminary review of Crestfield Advisory Partners Ltd. engagement and TGM disbursements, including overpayment analysis, approval process deficiencies, and timing correlations with permit issuancesBothAttorney work product containing legal analysis, mental impressions, and case assessment prepared in anticipation of litigation8No
16TRCH-PRIV-000091 – TRCH-PRIV-0000942025-04-02EmailHelen Whitmore, Whitmore & Sharpe LLPConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPEmail declining voluntary interview request on behalf of former VP, Africa Operations, citing potential criminal exposureBothCommunication between counsel reflecting litigation strategy and legal positions4No
17TRCH-PRIV-000095 – TRCH-PRIV-0001082025-04-03MemorandumSteven Hollander and Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum summarizing forensic accounting findings to date regarding payment flows from TGH to Crestfield Advisory Partners Ltd. and TGM local disbursements, including invoice analysis, cash withdrawal review, and in-kind benefit assessmentBothAttorney work product prepared in anticipation of litigation at direction of counsel, incorporating and analyzing forensic expert findings; reflects attorney mental impressions and legal conclusions14Yes (2 — summary payment tables prepared by Pinnacle Forensic Advisory LLC at direction of counsel)
18TRCH-PRIV-000109 – TRCH-PRIV-0001182025-04-07MemorandumConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPFile (Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Privileged witness interview memorandum documenting interview of Nadia Berenson, VP Compliance and Ethics, Torchlight Mining Corp., conducted April 7, 2025, in Toronto, covering receipt and escalation of whistleblower complaint, Crestfield engagement awareness, and compliance training programBothAttorney work product documenting factual investigation conducted by counsel in anticipation of litigation; reflects attorney mental impressions and selective memorialization10NoInterview conducted pursuant to Upjohn corporate representation warnings
19TRCH-PRIV-000119 – TRCH-PRIV-0001272025-04-08MemorandumSteven Hollander and Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPFile (Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Privileged witness interview memorandum documenting interview of Diane Fournier, VP Finance, Torchlight Mining Corp., conducted April 8, 2025, in Toronto, covering TGH/TGM financial consolidation oversight, Crestfield invoice approval processes, and general ledger coding practicesBothAttorney work product documenting factual investigation conducted by counsel in anticipation of litigation; reflects attorney mental impressions and selective memorialization9NoInterview conducted pursuant to Upjohn corporate representation warnings
20TRCH-PRIV-000128 – TRCH-PRIV-0001392025-04-09MemorandumConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPFile (Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Privileged witness interview memorandum documenting interview of Patricia Sung, General Counsel, Torchlight Mining Corp., conducted April 9, 2025, in Toronto, covering Audit Committee review, Crestfield engagement awareness, Delacroix resignation circumstances, and response to SEC and DOJ inquiriesBothAttorney work product documenting factual investigation conducted by counsel in anticipation of litigation; reflects attorney mental impressions and selective memorialization12NoInterview conducted pursuant to Upjohn corporate representation warnings
21TRCH-PRIV-000140 – TRCH-PRIV-0001462025-04-10MemorandumJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum summarizing review of TGH BVI corporate records in coordination with Catherine Whitfield of Hargrove Whitfield LLP, including board resolutions authorizing the Crestfield engagement, account opening documents at Meridian Commercial Bank, and signatory authoritiesBothAttorney work product reflecting legal analysis of corporate records obtained at counsel's direction; common interest materials shared with BVI co-counsel7Yes (1 — annotated signatory authority chart)Underlying unannotated corporate records produced as TRCH-SEC-002190 – TRCH-SEC-002220
22TRCH-PRIV-000147 – TRCH-PRIV-0001532025-04-14EmailConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Privileged email providing investigation status update as of April 2025, including summary of completed first-wave witness interviews, preliminary forensic accounting findings, SEC production status, and upcoming second-wave interview scheduleAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication from counsel to client providing legal advice and investigation status in connection with pending government investigations7Yes (1 — draft interview schedule for second wave)
23TRCH-PRIV-000154 – TRCH-PRIV-0001642025-04-15MemorandumJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum evaluating Torchlight's existing anti-corruption compliance program against DOJ/SEC guidance, identifying gaps in third-party due diligence, Delegation of Authority Policy enforcement, training records for West African operations, and gift/hospitality trackingBothAttorney work product containing legal analysis and evaluation of compliance program adequacy prepared in anticipation of litigation11No
24TRCH-PRIV-000165 – TRCH-PRIV-0001742025-04-18MemorandumSteven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum analyzing potential violations of FCPA books and records (Section 13(b)(2)(A)) and internal controls (Section 13(b)(2)(B)) provisions based on mischaracterization of payments, absence of dual-approval controls, and failure to detect the alleged schemeBothAttorney work product containing legal analysis of statutory provisions and application to investigated facts; reflects attorney mental impressions10No
25TRCH-PRIV-000175 – TRCH-PRIV-0001822025-04-22MemorandumJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPMemorandum summarizing legal advice received from Maître Salif Ndong of Ndong & Keïta Cabinet Juridique regarding Ganaran criminal and administrative consequences, potential mining license revocation risk, and applicable Ganaran anti-corruption statutesBothAttorney-client communication reflecting legal advice from local co-counsel shared under common interest; work product reflecting counsel's analysis of foreign law exposure8No
26TRCH-PRIV-000183 – TRCH-PRIV-0001912025-04-28MemorandumSteven Hollander and Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPFile (Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Privileged witness interview memorandum documenting interview of Thomas Achebe, Finance Director, Torchlight Ganara Mining S.A., conducted April 28, 2025 via video from Ganara, covering processing of Crestfield invoices, cash withdrawal procedures at Regency International Bank, and directions received regarding general ledger codingBothAttorney work product documenting factual investigation conducted by counsel in anticipation of litigation; reflects attorney mental impressions and selective memorialization9NoInterview conducted pursuant to Upjohn corporate representation warnings
27TRCH-PRIV-000192 – TRCH-PRIV-0002002025-04-29MemorandumSteven Hollander and Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPFile (Calderwood & Harkness LLP)Privileged witness interview memorandum documenting interview of Kwame Mensah, Procurement Manager, Torchlight Ganara Mining S.A., conducted April 29, 2025 via video from Ganara, covering knowledge of vehicle purchases and in-kind benefits provided to government officials, procurement procedures, and interactions with former Country ManagerBothAttorney work product documenting factual investigation conducted by counsel in anticipation of litigation; reflects attorney mental impressions and selective memorialization9NoInterview conducted pursuant to Upjohn corporate representation warnings
28TRCH-PRIV-000201 – TRCH-PRIV-0002102025-05-12MemorandumConrad Ashby and Steven Hollander, Calderwood & Harkness LLPPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.; Dr. Eleanor Fiske, Audit Committee Chair; Warren Ogilvy, Audit Committee Member; Marguerite Chen, Audit Committee MemberMemorandum recommending specific remediation measures for Torchlight's anti-corruption compliance program, including enhanced third-party due diligence, revised Delegation of Authority Policy, mandatory training, audit rights requirements, and consideration of independent compliance monitorAttorney-Client PrivilegeCommunication from counsel to client providing legal advice regarding compliance program remediation10No
29TRCH-PRIV-000211 – TRCH-PRIV-0002482025-05-15Report (Draft)Conrad Ashby, Victoria Chambers, Steven Hollander, and Jasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLPDr. Eleanor Fiske, Audit Committee Chair; Warren Ogilvy, Audit Committee Member; Marguerite Chen, Audit Committee Member, Torchlight Mining Corp. BoardPatricia Sung, Torchlight Mining Corp.Draft interim investigation report summarizing findings to date regarding suspected improper payments, identified payment channels, government officials, witness interview results, forensic accounting status, compliance program assessment, and preliminary recommendations regarding voluntary self-disclosure, remediation, and individual accountabilityBothAttorney-client communication providing comprehensive legal advice and investigation findings; attorney work product reflecting mental impressions, legal analysis, case strategy, and conclusions prepared in anticipation of litigation38Yes (3 — summary financial tables, timeline chart, and remediation roadmap)Draft — subject to revision

[sheet: Summary Statistics]

CategoryCount / Value
Total Documents Withheld29
Total Pages Withheld237
Bates RangeTRCH-PRIV-000001 – TRCH-PRIV-000248
Documents Withheld — Attorney-Client Privilege Only7
Documents Withheld — Work Product Doctrine Only0
Documents Withheld — Both Attorney-Client Privilege and Work Product22
Date Range of Withheld DocumentsMarch 5, 2025 – May 15, 2025
Attachments Withheld9 (across 7 entries)
Privilege Log Prepared ByJasmine Thornton, Calderwood & Harkness LLP
Privilege Log DateMay 20, 2025
C&H Matter No.1039-00005
SEC File No.HO-14892
ClientTorchlight Mining Corp.
Production Bates Prefix (non-privileged)TRCH-SEC-
Privilege Bates PrefixTRCH-PRIV-