FR EA

Extract to table

Pull the structured facts out of a document: parties, dates, amounts, obligations.

Extract to table / draft-rebuttal-expert-report-rosser.docx
draft-rebuttal-expert-report-rosser.docx · 1012-00005

Parties

Vantor Holdings Corp
Stonefield Logistics Group Inc
Director Kensington Analytics Group LLC
Analyst Kensington Analytics Group LLC
Harkness LLP
Kensington Analytics Group LLC
Vantor Transport Services LLC
Ashford Meridian LLP

Dates

August 10, 2023
October 28, 2022
May 15, 2023
March 15, 2019
January 18, 2022
February 14, 2022
March 4, 2022
November 12, 2021
September 22, 2021
July 10, 2023

Amounts

$8.2
$1.7
$95.4
$67.23
$625
$375
$214,300
$1.42
$1.28
$118

Obligations

Moreover, any true volume shortfall analysis for CY3 must account for the fact that the termination itself cut short the year, and any prorated obligations should be calculated accordingly
My analysis incorporates the following adjustments, each of which is necessary to produce a damages figure that reflects economic reality: (i) Realistic volume projections accounting for VTS's actual performance trajectory and the likelihood that VTS's deteriorating SLO compliance would have resulted in reduced freight volume even in the absence of termination; (ii) Appropriate margin assumptions based on VTS's audited financial statements and industry benchmark data, rather than unverified self-reported account-level margins; (iii) Offsets for SLG's own volume shortfall claims that VTS would assert are owed under the ACV commitment, ensuring that damages are not inflated by volume projections that VTS itself alleges were not being met; (iv) Mitigation credit for revenue that VTS could have reasonably earned through diligent mitigation efforts, given the favorable freight market conditions prevailing in 2022; and (v) Present value discounting to reflect the time value of money, as future lost profits must be reduced to their present value at the time of breach