Extract to table
Pull the structured facts out of a document: parties, dates, amounts, obligations.
Extract to table / memo-mitigation-of-damages.docx
memo-mitigation-of-damages.docx
Parties
HARKNESS LLP
Vantor Holdings Corp
Stonefield Logistics Group Inc
Vantor Transport Services LLC
Capacity Vantor Transport Services LLC
Losei Realty Corp
See LKQ Corp
Motors LLC
Dates
January 30, 2023
March 4, 2022
January 13, 2023
March 6, 2023
March 15, 2019
April 1, 2019
March 31, 2024
January 18, 2022
February 17, 2022
February 14, 2022
Amounts
$1.4
$95.4
$18.7
$5.2
$2.87
$67.23
$28.17
$43.2
$216
$387,400
Obligations
The doctrine of avoidable consequences requires that a party claiming damages arising from a breach of contract — even where that party contends the termination itself was wrongful — must exercise reasonable diligence and ordinary care to reduce the quantum of its loss
As the Court of Appeals stated in Losei Realty, the injured party must act "with a view to keeping damages down, as every prudent person is expected to do
However, the injured party must make reasonable, good-faith efforts to minimize its losses when the opportunity to do so presents itself
In the context of a lost contract, the primary obligation is affirmative: the injured party must seek replacement business, redeploy assets, and reduce unnecessary costs
(ii) If the clause is unenforceable (as Stonefield argues): If the liquidated damages clause is struck down as an unenforceable penalty, Vantor's recovery on this component reverts to actual damages, which must be proven with reasonable certainty
At this stage, Vantor must come forward with evidence of its actual efforts — or the absence of available opportunities — to rebut Stonefield's showing