Extract to table
Pull the structured facts out of a document: parties, dates, amounts, obligations.
Extract to table / rebuttal-expert-report-ramanathan.docx
rebuttal-expert-report-ramanathan.docx
Parties
Defendants Cascade Retail Holdings Inc
Pinnacle Market Group Inc
Managing Director Brindoval Analytics LLC
Brindoval Analytics LLC
Harkness LLP
Cascade Retail Holdings Inc
Vertex Commerce Inc
Non-transitory Inc
Dates
August 29, 2025
August 18, 2025
July 2, 2025
June 1, 2019
Amounts
$1,800,000
$757
$340
$195
$145
$4.7
$14.5
$3.1
$11.4
$43.7
Obligations
If such a price increase would be unprofitable because sufficient customers would substitute to products outside the candidate market, then the candidate market is too narrow and must be expanded to include additional substitutes
2274 (2018), established that courts must consider both sides of a two-sided transaction platform when assessing competitive effects
If the SSNIP test is corrected to account for supply-side substitution and dynamic competitive responses, the relevant market must be broadened to include all e-commerce retail
Keenan's narrow market definition for the sake of argument — which I do not — the post-merger HHI of 2,856 must be evaluated in proper context
Moreover, even this reduced gross UPP must be evaluated against the efficiency credit from Cascade's documented merger-specific efficiencies