CONFIDENTIAL — SUBJECT TO NON-DISCLOSURE AGREEMENT DATED SEPTEMBER 5, 2023
October 8, 2023
CALDERWOOD & HARKNESS LLP 599 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10022
SUPPLEMENTAL DUE DILIGENCE REQUEST LIST INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY AND TECHNOLOGY
Prepared on behalf of:
Solara Digital Infrastructure LP 1200 Market Street, Suite 3400 Wilmington, DE 19801
Addressed to:
Ridgeway Phelps & Sato LLP 375 Park Avenue New York, NY 10152
Attention: Catherine Answorth, Esq.
As counsel to Cloudium Technologies plc
Matter No.: 1041-00003
Re: Proposed Acquisition of Cloudium Technologies plc — Supplemental Due Diligence Request List No. 2 (Intellectual Property and Technology)
Right-click to update Table of Contents
INTRODUCTORY INSTRUCTIONS
This Supplemental Due Diligence Request List No. 2 (this "Supplemental Request List") supplements the Preliminary Due Diligence Request List dated September 10, 2023 (the "Preliminary Request List"), previously delivered by Calderwood & Harkness LLP on behalf of Solara Digital Infrastructure LP ("Buyer") to Ridgeway Phelps & Sato LLP, as counsel to Cloudium Technologies plc (the "Company"). This Supplemental Request List focuses specifically on intellectual property, technology, data privacy, cybersecurity, and related matters, and should be read in conjunction with the Preliminary Request List. To the extent any item was previously requested in the Preliminary Request List, the inclusion of such item herein is intended to clarify or expand upon the scope of the prior request and is not intended to limit it in any respect.
All defined terms used herein shall have the meanings assigned to them in the Preliminary Request List unless otherwise defined or unless the context requires otherwise. Capitalized terms used herein that are not otherwise defined shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the Draft Transaction Agreement circulated on October 2, 2023.
References to "the Company" refer to Cloudium Technologies plc (Company No. 09734521, registered at 45 Broadwick Street, London W1F 0DB, United Kingdom; US headquarters at 600 Townsend Street, Suite 800, San Francisco, CA 94103) and, unless the context otherwise requires, its direct and indirect subsidiaries, including without limitation:
• Cloudium Technologies UK Ltd. (Company No. 11287456, registered in England and Wales, with offices in London and Manchester);
• Cloudium Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. (registered in Bangalore, Karnataka, India); and
• Cloudium Solutions GmbH (registered in Berlin, Germany).
Where a request is directed to the Company, it is intended to encompass all of the foregoing entities and any other direct or indirect subsidiaries, affiliates, joint ventures, or special purpose vehicles of the Company, unless context clearly indicates otherwise.
All responsive documents and information should be uploaded to the virtual data room established for this transaction (the "VDR"), to which access was granted on September 18, 2023, in the designated IP and Technology folder structure. Where practicable, documents should be organized in accordance with the section and subsection numbering used in this Supplemental Request List. All documents should be uploaded in searchable PDF format (with OCR applied, where applicable), native format (for spreadsheets, databases, and source code documentation), or such other format as may be mutually agreed.
Where documents or information responsive to a particular request are voluminous, the Company may provide summaries, indices, or catalogs in the first instance, provided that the underlying documents are made available for review upon request by Buyer or its advisors. Any such summary should include sufficient detail to enable Buyer to determine whether review of the underlying documents is warranted.
The requests contained herein cover all jurisdictions in which the Company and its subsidiaries operate, including without limitation the United States, the United Kingdom, India, Germany, and any other applicable jurisdiction. Where a request calls for documents or information by jurisdiction, please provide responses organized by jurisdiction to the extent practicable.
To the extent any documents or information responsive to a request are subject to attorney-client privilege, work product protection, or other applicable privilege or protection, please identify such materials and provide a privilege log describing the nature of each withheld document, the date, the author(s) and recipient(s), and the basis for the privilege claim, in sufficient detail for Buyer's counsel to evaluate the claim. We reserve all rights to challenge any such claim.
This Supplemental Request List is not intended to be exhaustive and should not be construed as limiting the scope of Buyer's due diligence investigation. Buyer reserves the right to request additional documents and information as the due diligence process continues.
SECTION I: INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY PORTFOLIO — GENERAL OVERVIEW
1.1 IP Portfolio Summary
1.1.1. A comprehensive schedule (in spreadsheet format) of all intellectual property rights owned, co-owned, licensed (whether inbound or outbound), or otherwise used by the Company and each of its subsidiaries, organized first by type of intellectual property right (patents and patent applications; trademarks, service marks, and trade dress; copyrights and copyright applications; trade secrets and proprietary know-how; and domain names) and second by the entity within the corporate group that is the record owner, applicant, registrant, or licensee of such intellectual property right (i.e., separately identifying assets held by Cloudium Technologies plc, Cloudium Technologies UK Ltd., Cloudium Technologies India Pvt. Ltd., and Cloudium Solutions GmbH, respectively).
1.1.2. For each item of registered or applied-for intellectual property included in the schedule described in Request 1.1.1 above, the schedule should include, at a minimum, the following information:
(a) the title or mark;
(b) the registration number and/or application number (as applicable);
(c) the filing date;
(d) the registration date (if registered);
(e) the jurisdiction(s) in which the registration or application was filed;
(f) the current status of the registration or application (e.g., registered, pending, published, allowed, abandoned, expired, opposed);
(g) the record owner or applicant (specifying the legal entity within the corporate group);
(h) the name of the inventor(s) or author(s) (as applicable);
(i) any co-owners or joint applicants (whether within or outside the corporate group); and
(j) any liens, encumbrances, security interests, or restrictions on the intellectual property.
1.1.3. Identification of any material unregistered intellectual property rights not included in the schedule described above, including unregistered trademarks used in commerce, common law copyrights in material works, and material trade secrets.
1.1.4. Description of the Company's processes and systems for tracking and managing its intellectual property portfolio, including the names of any IP management software or databases used and the individual(s) responsible for portfolio management.
1.2 Patents and Patent Applications
1.2.1. A complete schedule of all patents and patent applications (including utility patents, design patents, provisional applications, PCT international applications, and national phase entries) owned or co-owned by the Company and each of its subsidiaries, in all jurisdictions worldwide. The schedule should include the information specified in Request 1.1.2 above, together with the following additional information for each patent or application:
(a) the technology area or product line to which the patent or application relates;
(b) the named inventor(s) and their employment relationship to the Company at the time of invention;
(c) the patent family to which the patent or application belongs (including all related continuations, continuations-in-part, divisionals, reissues, and foreign counterparts);
(d) the current prosecution status and the name of outside patent counsel handling prosecution;
(e) the priority date and any claims to priority; and
(f) the expected expiration date (taking into account any patent term adjustments or extensions).
1.2.2. Copies of all issued patents (including all claims, specifications, and drawings) and all pending patent applications (including all claims, specifications, drawings, and any published applications).
1.2.3. Complete patent prosecution history files for all pending patent applications, including all office actions, examiner interview summaries, responses to office actions, amendments, declarations, information disclosure statements (IDS), and any other correspondence with the relevant patent office.
1.2.4. Identification of any continuation applications, continuation-in-part applications, divisional applications, reissue applications, or requests for continued examination (RCE) filed or contemplated in connection with any of the Company's patents or patent applications.
1.2.5. Details of any inter partes review (IPR), post-grant review (PGR), covered business method review (CBM), re-examination (ex parte or inter partes), interference, derivation, or opposition proceedings involving any of the Company's patents or patent applications, whether as petitioner/challenger or patent owner, in any jurisdiction. For each such proceeding, please provide:
(a) the proceeding number and tribunal;
(b) the patent(s) or application(s) at issue;
(c) the identity of the opposing party;
(d) the claims at issue;
(e) the current status of the proceeding; and
(f) copies of all petitions, patent owner responses, decisions, and key filings.
1.2.6. A schedule showing the maintenance fee (annuity) payment status for all issued patents in all jurisdictions, including the date of the last maintenance fee payment and the due date and amount of the next maintenance fee payment. Identification of any patents for which a maintenance fee payment has been missed or for which a surcharge has been paid.
1.2.7. Identification of any patents or patent applications that have been abandoned, allowed to lapse, withdrawn, or are subject to terminal disclaimers, together with an explanation of the reason for each such action and the date on which it occurred.
1.2.8. Identification of any patents or patent applications that are subject to any obligation to license or grant rights to any third party (e.g., under standards-essential patent commitments, FRAND/RAND obligations, or cross-license agreements).
1.3 Trademarks, Service Marks, and Trade Dress
1.3.1. A complete schedule of all registered and pending trademarks, service marks, trade dress registrations, and applications in all jurisdictions worldwide, including the information specified in Request 1.1.2 above, together with the following additional information:
(a) the mark as registered or applied for (word mark, stylized mark, or design mark, with images where applicable);
(b) the goods and/or services covered by the registration or application (including class numbers);
(c) the basis for filing (e.g., use in commerce, intent to use, foreign registration);
(d) the date of first use and date of first use in commerce (for US registrations);
(e) the next renewal date and any upcoming Section 8 or Section 15 filing deadlines (for US registrations); and
(f) the current status, including whether any Statement of Use, Declaration of Use, or renewal filing is pending or overdue.
1.3.2. Copies of all trademark and service mark registration certificates, and copies of all pending applications (as filed).
1.3.3. Details of any opposition, cancellation, expungement, or other adversarial proceedings before any trademark office or tribunal involving any of the Company's trademarks, service marks, or trade dress, whether as applicant/registrant or opposing party. For each such proceeding, provide the proceeding number, tribunal, opposing party, mark(s) at issue, current status, and copies of all key filings.
1.3.4. Identification of any unregistered trademarks, service marks, brand names, product names, logos, slogans, or trade dress used in commerce by the Company that are not covered by a registration or pending application. For each such mark, provide a description of the mark, the goods and/or services with which it is used, the geographic scope of use, and the date of first use.
1.3.5. Copies of any trademark watch service reports or monitoring reports received by the Company within the past three years, and any notices of potential infringement or confusingly similar marks identified through such monitoring.
1.3.6. Copies of any coexistence agreements, consent-to-use agreements, concurrent use agreements, or other agreements with third parties relating to the use of trademarks or service marks that may be similar or potentially confusing with the Company's marks.
1.4 Copyrights
1.4.1. A schedule of all copyright registrations and pending copyright applications in all jurisdictions, including the registration/application number, title of the work, author(s), claimant, date of creation, date of first publication, date of registration, and jurisdiction.
1.4.2. Copies of all copyright registration certificates and pending applications.
1.4.3. Identification of all material copyrightable works created by or for the Company (whether or not registered), including but not limited to:
(a) software source code and object code for the Company's principal products and internal tools;
(b) software documentation, user manuals, and technical specifications;
(c) marketing materials, brochures, white papers, and promotional content;
(d) training materials, e-learning content, and certification programs;
(e) website content, blog posts, and other digital content;
(f) databases and data compilations; and
(g) audiovisual works, graphics, and design elements.
1.4.4. Copies of all copyright assignment agreements, work-for-hire agreements, or other agreements pursuant to which copyright in any material work was assigned or transferred to the Company by any employee, independent contractor, consultant, or third party.
1.5 Domain Names
1.5.1. A complete list of all domain names owned, registered, or controlled by the Company and each of its subsidiaries, including for each domain name:
(a) the domain name;
(b) the registrant (specifying the entity within the corporate group);
(c) the registrar;
(d) the date of registration;
(e) the expiration/renewal date;
(f) the auto-renewal status;
(g) the name server configuration;
(h) the WHOIS privacy/proxy service status; and
(i) whether the domain name is actively used (and, if so, the purpose — e.g., primary website, product-specific site, email, redirect, parked).
1.5.2. Identification of any domain name disputes, Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy (UDRP) proceedings, Uniform Rapid Suspension (URS) proceedings, cybersquatting claims, or other domain-name-related disputes involving the Company (whether as complainant or respondent), and copies of all related filings and decisions.
1.5.3. Identification of any domain names that are material to the Company's business but are not owned or controlled by the Company (e.g., domains held by third-party partners, former employees, or domain holding services).
1.6 Trade Secrets and Proprietary Know-How
1.6.1. A description of the Company's trade secret identification, classification, and protection policies and procedures, including any formal trade secret management program.
1.6.2. Identification (by category, without requiring disclosure of the trade secrets themselves) of the Company's material trade secrets and proprietary know-how, including but not limited to:
(a) proprietary algorithms (including any algorithms used in the Company's ERP, CRM, and business-intelligence platforms);
(b) customer data analytics methodologies and models;
(c) pricing models, competitive analysis frameworks, and go-to-market strategies;
(d) proprietary development methodologies, tools, and processes;
(e) engineering know-how, system architecture designs, and optimization techniques;
(f) customer lists, vendor lists, and business relationship information; and
(g) any other categories of confidential business or technical information that the Company considers to be trade secrets.
1.6.3. Description of the physical and technical safeguards employed by the Company to protect trade secret information, including access restrictions, encryption, facility security, network segmentation, document classification and handling procedures, and employee exit protocols.
1.6.4. Copies of any trade secret audits, assessments, or inventories conducted by the Company (whether internally or by outside counsel or consultants) within the past five years.
1.6.5. Identification of any instances in which the Company believes its trade secrets may have been misappropriated, disclosed without authorization, or otherwise compromised, and a description of the remedial actions taken.
SECTION II: IP OWNERSHIP AND CHAIN OF TITLE
2.1 IP Assignment Agreements
2.1.1. Copies of all agreements (including assignment agreements, bills of sale, deeds of assignment, and instruments of transfer) pursuant to which any intellectual property was assigned, transferred, or conveyed to the Company or any of its subsidiaries by any person or entity, including founders, employees, independent contractors, consultants, former employers of key personnel, acquired companies, and third parties.
2.1.2. Identification of any gaps, defects, or unresolved issues in the chain of title for any material intellectual property asset of the Company, including any situation in which an assignment was not executed, was defectively executed, or was executed but not recorded with the relevant intellectual property office.
2.1.3. Copies of all work-for-hire agreements entered into by the Company with any person or entity, under which works were created for the Company as works made for hire within the meaning of applicable copyright law.
2.1.4. Copies of any confirmatory assignments, nunc pro tunc assignments, or corrective assignments executed to address chain-of-title issues.
2.2 Employee and Contractor IP Assignment Provisions
2.2.1. Copies of the Company's standard form employee invention assignment and confidentiality agreement (or equivalent proprietary information and inventions agreement, or PIIA) for each jurisdiction in which the Company employs personnel, including:
(a) United States (California and any other state-specific versions);
(b) United Kingdom;
(c) India; and
(d) Germany.
2.2.2. For each jurisdiction listed above, the percentage of current employees who have executed the applicable IP assignment agreement or equivalent, and the percentage of current independent contractors and consultants who have executed the applicable IP assignment agreement or equivalent.
2.2.3. Identification of any current or former employees or independent contractors who have:
(a) refused to execute an IP assignment agreement;
(b) executed an IP assignment agreement but carved out or excluded pre-existing inventions, works, or other intellectual property from the scope of the assignment (together with a description or list of such carved-out IP); or
(c) asserted any claim of ownership, co-ownership, or other right in any intellectual property developed during the course of their engagement with the Company.
2.2.4. With respect to the Company's research and development personnel at Cloudium Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. (which we understand employs approximately 2,400 individuals engaged in R&D and support functions), please provide:
(a) the form of employment agreement and IP assignment agreement used for India-based R&D personnel;
(b) confirmation of the percentage of India-based R&D personnel who have executed such agreements;
(c) identification of any India-specific legal limitations on the enforceability of employee IP assignment provisions (including under the Indian Patents Act, 1970, and the Indian Copyright Act, 1957);
(d) identification of any key R&D personnel at Cloudium Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. who have carved out pre-existing IP or who have not executed IP assignment agreements; and
(e) a description of any IP developed by India-based personnel that is owned by or could be claimed by such personnel (or any former employer of such personnel) rather than by the Company.
2.3 IP Developed by Subsidiaries
2.3.1. A description of the IP development activities conducted at each subsidiary entity, including the nature of the development work performed, the approximate number of personnel engaged in such activities, and the location(s) at which such work is performed. Specifically, please describe:
(a) Cloudium Technologies plc (US headquarters, San Francisco) — approximately how many personnel are engaged in IP development and the nature of their work;
(b) Cloudium Technologies UK Ltd. (approximately 1,200 employees in London and Manchester) — the nature and scope of IP development activities performed by UK personnel;
(c) Cloudium Technologies India Pvt. Ltd. (approximately 2,400 employees in Bangalore) — the nature and scope of IP development, engineering, quality assurance, and related activities performed by India personnel; and
(d) Cloudium Solutions GmbH (approximately 400 employees in Berlin) — the nature and scope of IP development, product localization, and related activities performed by German personnel.
2.3.2. Copies of all intercompany agreements governing the ownership, licensing, development, cost-sharing, or use of intellectual property among the Company and its subsidiaries, including:
(a) intercompany IP license agreements;
(b) intercompany cost-sharing agreements or cost contribution arrangements;
(c) intercompany services agreements relating to R&D, engineering, or IP development;
(d) transfer pricing documentation (including transfer pricing studies, benchmarking analyses, and advance pricing agreements) related to IP development and ownership among the Company and its subsidiaries; and
(e) any intercompany agreements relating to the allocation of income, costs, or risks associated with IP development.
2.3.3. Identification of any intellectual property that is owned by a subsidiary entity rather than by Cloudium Technologies plc (the parent company), and a description of the basis for such ownership (e.g., the IP was developed locally, was assigned to the subsidiary, or was registered in the subsidiary's name).
2.3.4. Description of any plans or actions taken to centralize IP ownership within the parent entity or to rationalize the allocation of IP among the Company and its subsidiaries.
2.4 Government-Funded IP
2.4.1. Identification of any intellectual property developed, in whole or in part, with funding from any government source (federal, state, local, or foreign), including grants, contracts, subcontracts, cooperative agreements, or other government funding mechanisms. With respect to such government-funded IP, please identify:
(a) the specific government funding source and the relevant contract, grant, or agreement number;
(b) the nature of the IP developed;
(c) the extent to which government funding contributed to the development;
(d) any government rights attaching to such IP, including march-in rights, government use licenses, or unlimited rights; and
(e) any reporting obligations (e.g., invention disclosure, election of title, utilization reports) required under the applicable funding agreement.
2.4.2. With particular reference to the Company's relationship with Aegis Federal Solutions Inc. (which we understand accounts for approximately $84,000,000 in annual recurring revenue and involves the provision of services to US government end-users), please provide:
(a) copies of all contracts, subcontracts, or agreements between the Company and Aegis Federal Solutions Inc. (or between the Company and any US government agency) that include provisions regarding IP ownership, licensing, or data rights;
(b) identification of any IP developed under or in connection with such contracts that is subject to government rights under FAR Part 27, DFARS Part 227, or any other applicable government IP regulations;
(c) identification of any "subject inventions" (as defined in FAR 52.227-11 or equivalent clause) for which the Company has or has not elected title; and
(d) copies of any invention disclosures, confirmatory licenses, or other filings made with or on behalf of the US government relating to IP developed under such contracts.
2.5 University and Research Institution Collaborations
2.5.1. Copies of all agreements between the Company and any university, research institution, national laboratory, or academic collaborator under which intellectual property was developed, co-developed, licensed, or otherwise obtained, including sponsored research agreements, collaborative research agreements, joint development agreements, and material transfer agreements.
2.5.2. For each such agreement, please identify:
(a) the university or research institution;
(b) the nature of the research conducted;
(c) the IP developed or expected to be developed under the agreement;
(d) the allocation of ownership of resulting IP (sole ownership by the Company, sole ownership by the institution, joint ownership, or other arrangement);
(e) any license rights retained by the institution (including reserved research use rights);
(f) any publication rights or restrictions;
(g) any commercialization milestones or diligence obligations; and
(h) any terms that may affect the Company's ability to freely use, license, or assign the resulting IP.
2.5.3. Description of any joint ownership arrangements for IP arising from university or research institution collaborations, including any joint ownership agreements or understandings regarding each party's right to exploit the jointly owned IP.
SECTION III: IP LICENSES — INBOUND
3.1 Inbound License Agreements
3.1.1. Copies of all material agreements under which the Company or any of its subsidiaries licenses, receives, or otherwise obtains rights to use intellectual property from any third party, including but not limited to technology license agreements, patent license agreements, copyright license agreements, trademark license agreements, trade secret license agreements, and data license agreements.
3.1.2. A schedule (in spreadsheet format) of all such inbound license agreements, identifying for each agreement:
(a) the licensor;
(b) the licensed intellectual property (described with reasonable specificity);
(c) the scope of the license (exclusive or non-exclusive; field-of-use limitations, if any; territory);
(d) the term of the license (including any renewal provisions);
(e) the fee structure (one-time payment, ongoing royalties, minimum commitments, usage-based fees);
(f) any restrictions on sublicensing, assignment, or transfer;
(g) any change of control provisions, including provisions that would terminate the license, require consent to assignment, or modify the license terms upon a change of control of the Company;
(h) any anti-assignment provisions or provisions requiring consent for assignment (whether by operation of law, merger, or otherwise);
(i) any most-favored-nation or pricing parity provisions;
(j) any audit rights;
(k) any termination provisions (including termination for convenience, termination for cause, and termination upon insolvency or bankruptcy); and
(l) the current status of the agreement (active, expired, terminated, or in dispute).
3.1.3. With specific reference to the Technology License Agreement with Helix Data Systems GmbH (Frankfurt, Germany), which we understand contains a termination-for-change-of-control clause:
(a) a complete, unredacted copy of such agreement, including all amendments, addenda, side letters, and schedules;
(b) identification of all change of control provisions, anti-assignment provisions, and consent-required provisions in such agreement, with the relevant sections cited;
(c) an analysis of whether the proposed transaction structure (reverse triangular merger of Stratos Merger Sub Inc. with and into Cloudium Technologies plc, with the Company surviving as a wholly owned subsidiary of Buyer) constitutes a "change of control" or triggers any assignment provision under such agreement;
(d) identification of the consequences of triggering any such provision (termination, renegotiation, consent requirement, fee adjustment, etc.);
(e) the status of any communications with Helix Data Systems GmbH regarding the proposed transaction, including whether any consent or waiver has been sought or obtained; and
(f) the business significance of the licensed technology to the Company's products and operations, including an estimate of the cost and timeline that would be required to replace the licensed technology if the license were terminated.
3.2 Third-Party Software Licenses
3.2.1. A comprehensive schedule of all third-party commercial software licenses used by the Company in its products or internal operations, including but not limited to: